Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => The Wider Picture Overseas => Topic started by: WEX-RSB-FGH-BPW-PAD on August 22, 2014, 18:18:57



Title: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: WEX-RSB-FGH-BPW-PAD on August 22, 2014, 18:18:57
The current edition of a local newspaper, the Wexford People, reports that the line from Enniscorthy to Rosslare could be at risk of closure.

Extract from article below
Quote
IRISH RAIL REVIEW IS ALREADY UNDER WAY
WEXFORD^S railway station faces the threat of closure as Iarnr^d ^ireann reviews what have been dubbed Ireland^s underused ^ghost^ trains.
The days could be numbered too for the stations at both Rosslare Strand and Rosslare Harbour at the southern tip of what is one of the least used train routes in Ireland, according to figures published at the weekend.
On a daily basis, just 20 people board the train in Rosslare Europort and 18 arrive there by rail. In Rosslare Strand, the figure is 25 passengers boarding and 30 people arriving. In Wexford town, the daily number of passengers boarding trains is 81 while the arrival figure is 64.
An Iarnr^d ^ireann spokesman said a full review of routes and services is under way. In the light of this, there are fears that the Wexford to Rosslare Harbour link could be targeted for closure.
^ The cut-off point seems to be 100 passengers but they should be looking at the revenue, not passenger numbers,^ said former Labour councillor Joe Ryan, who has highlighted the threat to Wexford^s rail service over the past two years. WEXFORD COULD have a higher percentage of people paying for fares as opposed to passengers using free travel passes, Mr Ryan said.
Mr Ryan accused Irish Rail of not maximising its potential and of neglecting freight business development and the promotion of routes.
^ There seems to be a problem attracting business onto the rail line.^
^ They should stop concentrating on the soft option of cutting services and optimise the infrastructure they have,^ he said.
Mr Ryan warned that the closure of the Wexford to Rosslare line would result in a ^ hugely detrimental impact^ on Rosslare Harbour.
The latest passenger figures are based on internal Department of Transport briefing documents obtained by the Sunday Independent.

Dark days in the Emerald Isle.


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: eightf48544 on August 23, 2014, 16:23:33
Isn't one of the problems that the trains no longer make good connections with the ferries at Rosslare?

Also I believe Rosslare to Waterford line is mothballed and Waterford to Limerick Junction OOU so there is no way by rail from the South West.


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: grahame on August 23, 2014, 16:50:30
Isn't one of the problems that the trains no longer make good connections with the ferries at Rosslare?

Also I believe Rosslare to Waterford line is mothballed and Waterford to Limerick Junction OOU so there is no way by rail from the South West.

Waterford to Limerick Junction was, I recall, closed for a while but there are now 2 trains each way per day:
http://www.irishrail.ie/media/12-waterfordlimerick250920131.pdf?v=gc3u1co

Waterford to Rosslare has indeed been reduced to an engineer's siding.

Whereas connections at Fishguard to and from boats are good, a cynic might tell you that at Rosslare they're designed to fail.  I'm sure that's not quite the case, but I've certainly been put off travelling that route by the absence of a train connection off the afternoon boat from Fishguard to get me into Dublin in the late evening.  Reading more informed commentary here, I now understand that the issue is that Rosslare is on the very end of a long line south from Dublin which is very busy as you get closer to the city with single track capacity issues up there  between Greystones and Bray, and then there are long single track lengths further south too. "More important to look after daily commuters than those remaining ferryists who can't afford a car, and are too awkward to to fly" perhaps?

P.S.  I think it changed / good northbound evening connection for the high summer this year - just not advertised - or was I dreaming?


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: grahame on August 23, 2014, 17:03:32
OK - it is better at the moment

Boat from Fishguard at 02:45, 06:15 to 07:20 at Rosslare, 10:15 into Dublin
Boat from Fishguard at 14:30, 18:00 to 18:35 at Rosslare, 21:44 into Dublin
(previously was 18:00 to 05:35 at Rosslare, 08:46 into Dublin.  May revert at end of summer  :'( )

Train from Dublin at 16:37, 19:25 to 21:00 at Rosslare, 00:15 into Fishguard
Train from Dublin at 18:38, 21:28 to 09:00 next morning at Rosslare, 12:30 into Fishguard


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: Rhydgaled on August 24, 2014, 11:22:25
OK - it is better at the moment

Boat from Fishguard at 02:45, 06:15 to 07:20 at Rosslare, 10:15 into Dublin
Boat from Fishguard at 14:30, 18:00 to 18:35 at Rosslare, 21:44 into Dublin
(previously was 18:00 to 05:35 at Rosslare, 08:46 into Dublin.  May revert at end of summer  :'( )

Train from Dublin at 16:37, 19:25 to 21:00 at Rosslare, 00:15 into Fishguard
Train from Dublin at 18:38, 21:28 to 09:00 next morning at Rosslare, 12:30 into Fishguard
Looks like 3/4 sailings have something approaching connections then, just the 21:28 arrival for a 9am sailing that is totally hopeless.


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: WEX-RSB-FGH-BPW-PAD on August 30, 2014, 19:49:06
In addition to those of us taking the train to Rosslare there are a cohort who "park & sail" or are driven to the port and avail of SailRail onwards. SailRail wins over the private car in many instances particularly for a solitary traveller. For example between fuel and fare a trip from Co. Wexford to the Thames Valley/London will amount to several hundred euro whereas a SailRail advance return is just ^92. Secondly driving a car is essentially "down time" and one cannot do any work beyond thinking and listening to the radio. The train & ship option allows meaningful work by way of taking out a laptop or bundle of papers. On the trains here and on the ship there is free wifi. When wifi becomes universal on First Great Western and when it's rolled out on Arriva Trains Wales it will enhance the appeal of the SailRail offering for cross-channel passengers. A third consideration is that the rail timings are quite competitive. Granted a motorist will get to depart the port sooner than a SailRail passenger but this will be negated by the need for a rest break en route/possible congestion. Even the standby SailRail fare is only fractionally higher (^6/^7) whereas air fares can go sky high close to/on the travel date. Waterford Airport offers no flights to London and has no public transport connectivity bar a rural community bus one day a week. Even travelling by air it is necessary to factor in the cost of transport at both sides to make a fair comparison with the train & ship option. The cost of baggage on a flight can be a deciding factor for many. A concluding factor is that modern progressive economies such as Britain and Ireland need a balance in the transport mix rather than over-reliance on one node or mode.

The evening train ex Rosslare will revert to 17.55 from Monday 1st September. A problem is that the window of time between the arrival of the ship (18.00) and train departure is quite tight even in optimal conditions. From the ship coming to a standstill to arriving in the terminal building takes around ten minutes minimum (it's a fair walk along the enclosed elevated walkway between ship & terminal). Sometimes there are security/immigration checks prior to leaving the secure area on the first floor. Some passengers may need to collect baggage. Then there's the walk from the terminal to the station taking the best part of ten minutes. Add in some rain or heavy baggage and it can be seen that even in best conditions (Stena Line generally run a very punctual service) it's a bit of a rush. The connection into and out of the night sailings are much better and allow that necessary "wriggle room" (19.25 train arrival for 21.00 Fishguard sailing; 07.20 train departure out of 06.15 ferry arrival [02.45 ex Fishguard]). It should be noted that the ferry terminal building at Rosslare Europort is closed during the night so an overnight wait will entail accommodation in the village of Rosslare Harbour (there are a number of hotels and B&Bs).

Around a seventh of the length of the South Wexford (Rosslare Strand - Waterford) line is in regular use (several times a week) by freight trains travelling as far as Belview Port from the Waterford city direction. The key traditional catchment area of Rosslare are cities like Cork, Limerick and Waterford as well as towns across the region like Clonmel and Dungarvan. The bus services from Rosslare are not integrated with the onward rail services from Waterford (both the line via Clonmel to Limerick Junction for connections to the south & south west plus the line going north from Waterford via Kilkenny city to Carlow and Kildare). The Waterford-Clonmel-Limerick Junction line was temporarily closed (with replacement buses operating) between October 2003 and September 2004 while repairs were effected to Cahir Viaduct. The line was never out of use (OOU). If anyone comes across any publications stating this please drop them a polite line as it is a serious disservice to have misinformation like this circulating. In more recent years the line has seen significant expenditure with the majority of the permanent way now being continuous welded rail (CWR). It retains semaphore signalling though and the line limit is 50mph. InterCity railcars (ref: http://www.irishrail.ie/about-us/fleet) are the usual rolling stock on the line and the same trains form Dublin-Waterford/Waterford-Dublin trains earlier or later in the day.


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: grahame on April 03, 2024, 05:33:03
From the Irish Times (https://www.irishtimes.com/transport/2024/04/02/nta-considering-proposals-to-end-direct-rail-services-between-wexford-and-dublin/)

Quote
The National Transport Authority (NTA) is looking at plans to end direct rail services between Co Wexford and Dublin.

Two separate studies into capacity on the line are considering having passengers from the Rosslare line change from intercity trains to Dart carriages at either Wicklow or Greystones.

The move comes as passenger numbers on the line have grown strongly in recent years, with daily boardings at Wexford station in 2022 more than twice what they were in 2013. Passenger numbers at Enniscorthy have also grown significantly, while in May 2022, Irish Rail introduced a new night-time service between Gorey and Connolly, to meet demand.

The move also comes as Rosslare port is being rapidly expanded post-Brexit, including a new, €170 million facility for workers including gardaí, customs, HSE, and Department of Agriculture personnel, for which Minister of State Patrick O’Donovan initiated construction last September.

An interesting follow up to the old (nine year ago) story that the line was at risk.  Passenger numbers have grown dramatically and there's now a consideration of splitting the service at Greystones or Wexford - the idea being to free up paths on the suburban line into Dublin, and be able to run the diesel trains more frequently on the shorter part of the route.




Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: grahame on April 03, 2024, 06:02:38
Here is the current Monday to Friday timetable - Saturday and Sunday there are just 3 return trips each way

(http://www.wellho.net/pix/dub_ros_24.jpg)

The connections ...

05:30 and 17:30 arrivals in Rosslare from Fishguard
So that's the 07:20 train or the 05:35 next morning to carry on to Dublin

08:15 and 19:30 departures from Rosslare to Fishguard
So that's an arrival into Rosslare at 20:42 the previous evening from Dublin, or at 16:33

North of Bray / Greystones, into Dublin, the trains don't seem to have a regular in-the-hour pattern to them, and are (yes, I admit) a darned nuisance between almost clock face Dart services; they often seem to get stuck behind the Dart and the journey takes an age.


Title: Re: Enniscorthy-Wexford-Rosslare Strand-Rosslare Europort at risk of closure
Post by: CyclingSid on April 03, 2024, 16:22:53
Unhappy senator https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/0403/1441381-dublin-rosslare-train/ (https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/0403/1441381-dublin-rosslare-train/)
I think this is not the last of this.



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net