Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => The Wider Picture in the United Kingdom => Topic started by: Chris from Nailsea on May 12, 2018, 00:04:22



Title: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: Chris from Nailsea on May 12, 2018, 00:04:22
From the BBC (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-44082605):

Quote
M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend

(https://ichef-1.bbci.co.uk/news/660/cpsprodpb/15945/production/_101298388_de46-1.jpg)
The M1 is being closed so a bridge can be put in place for the new Kegworth bypass in Leicestershire

Drivers including football fans and people catching flights have been warned to expect disruption while part of the M1 is closed over the weekend.

Junctions 23A to 24, near East Midlands Airport, will shut from 22:00 BST on Friday to 15:00 on Sunday.

Fulham FC fans had asked for the closure to be put back an hour because of their match against Derby County.

But Segro, which is putting a bridge in place for a new bypass. said it had advised of the closures since March.

Highways England authorised the motorway closure but is not involved in the construction of the Kegworth bypass.

Former MP Tom Greatrex, who is chairman of the Fulham Supporters Trust, expects to be stuck in congested traffic for several hours after leaving the Pride Park stadium in Derby on Friday night.  He asked Highways England if they could close the road an hour later.

"It's not Highways England's fault as the game has been scheduled at short notice on a Friday night, but I thought it might make a bit of sense to avoid a whole load of chaos by starting an hour later," he said. "The closure is going to start at 10 o'clock and at about quarter to ten, roughly, there will be about 30,000 other people coming out of the Derby ground. I would expect a chunk of those would normally be heading towards the M1 by car."

Segro said in a statement: "This project has taken months of intricate work with numerous organisations and we began advising of the closures in March to help people plan their diversions.  Given the high level of planning and coordination involved in this project, we regret that we can't change the timings this close to start of the operation.  We apologise for any inconvenience caused."

Traffic was stopped for more than four hours on Friday morning on the northbound carriageway of the same stretch of motorway.  This was after a truck was involved in a crash and shed its load.


It's not just on the railways where significant engineering maintenance / improvement work has to be done, sometime or other.  ::)



Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: grahame on May 12, 2018, 06:34:54
From the BBC (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-44082605):

Quote
Former MP Tom Greatrex, who is chairman of the Fulham Supporters Trust, expects to be stuck in congested traffic for several hours after leaving the Pride Park stadium in Derby on Friday night.  He asked Highways England if they could close the road an hour later.

"It's not Highways England's fault as the game has been scheduled at short notice on a Friday night, but I thought it might make a bit of sense to avoid a whole load of chaos by starting an hour later," he said. "The closure is going to start at 10 o'clock and at about quarter to ten, roughly, there will be about 30,000 other people coming out of the Derby ground. I would expect a chunk of those would normally be heading towards the M1 by car."


It's not just on the railways where significant engineering maintenance / improvement work has to be done, sometime or other.  ::)


A fine example of a major sporting event planned at late notice after traffic infrastructure closure for works has been planned at what was anticipated to be a quiet time.

Common sense comment and request for a start about an hour later from Tom Greatrex. But he's right only to ask (and not demand with indignation) in my view. Criticism may be due to the people who scheduled the match to clash, but even there we don't know if they were aware of / checked for other goings on, how real (an how much of a storm in a teacup this is), and what other constraints there were.


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: TaplowGreen on May 12, 2018, 09:15:59
From the BBC (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-44082605):

Quote
Former MP Tom Greatrex, who is chairman of the Fulham Supporters Trust, expects to be stuck in congested traffic for several hours after leaving the Pride Park stadium in Derby on Friday night.  He asked Highways England if they could close the road an hour later.

"It's not Highways England's fault as the game has been scheduled at short notice on a Friday night, but I thought it might make a bit of sense to avoid a whole load of chaos by starting an hour later," he said. "The closure is going to start at 10 o'clock and at about quarter to ten, roughly, there will be about 30,000 other people coming out of the Derby ground. I would expect a chunk of those would normally be heading towards the M1 by car."


It's not just on the railways where significant engineering maintenance / improvement work has to be done, sometime or other.  ::)


A fine example of a major sporting event planned at late notice after traffic infrastructure closure for works has been planned at what was anticipated to be a quiet time.

Common sense comment and request for a start about an hour later from Tom Greatrex. But he's right only to ask (and not demand with indignation) in my view. Criticism may be due to the people who scheduled the match to clash, but even there we don't know if they were aware of / checked for other goings on, how real (an how much of a storm in a teacup this is), and what other constraints there were.

It was a play off semi final so not a scheduled fixture in the normal run of things, the teams/venue wouldn't have been known until the end of the season a week or two ago.

Pride Park is only a mile or so from Derby station but sadly the last train back to London for Fulham fans left before the match finished which would at least in part explain the vast numbers driving instead. Perhaps a more joined up approach from the transport providers would have helped?



Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: didcotdean on May 12, 2018, 12:20:59
There possibly might have been an option to flip the fixtures round as it is done over two legs, but I guess they didn't want their supporters to travel to Derby for a Monday night fixture either.


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: Electric train on May 13, 2018, 08:13:05
From the BBC (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-44082605):

Quote
Former MP Tom Greatrex, who is chairman of the Fulham Supporters Trust, expects to be stuck in congested traffic for several hours after leaving the Pride Park stadium in Derby on Friday night.  He asked Highways England if they could close the road an hour later.

"It's not Highways England's fault as the game has been scheduled at short notice on a Friday night, but I thought it might make a bit of sense to avoid a whole load of chaos by starting an hour later," he said. "The closure is going to start at 10 o'clock and at about quarter to ten, roughly, there will be about 30,000 other people coming out of the Derby ground. I would expect a chunk of those would normally be heading towards the M1 by car."


It's not just on the railways where significant engineering maintenance / improvement work has to be done, sometime or other.  ::)


A fine example of a major sporting event planned at late notice after traffic infrastructure closure for works has been planned at what was anticipated to be a quiet time.

Common sense comment and request for a start about an hour later from Tom Greatrex. But he's right only to ask (and not demand with indignation) in my view. Criticism may be due to the people who scheduled the match to clash, but even there we don't know if they were aware of / checked for other goings on, how real (an how much of a storm in a teacup this is), and what other constraints there were.

So this numpty wants a project that has more than likely been planned for 2 years, several hundred construction workers and their plant mobilised, local authorities, Police etc made ready; the date of the closure published ....................  ???

For a football match that was planned at the drop of a hat ....................... really  :-\

And this person is supposed to be an MP, I thought they were supposed to be concerned about "public sector" be more efficient like the "private sector" ..................... 


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: ellendune on May 13, 2018, 08:30:48
And this person is supposed to be an MP, I thought they were supposed to be concerned about "public sector" be more efficient like the "private sector" ..................... 

No it is the fact that such people have such little understanding which makes our public services so inefficient despite the skills of those 'experts' trying to run them. 


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: TaplowGreen on May 13, 2018, 08:49:14
From the BBC (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-44082605):

Quote
Former MP Tom Greatrex, who is chairman of the Fulham Supporters Trust, expects to be stuck in congested traffic for several hours after leaving the Pride Park stadium in Derby on Friday night.  He asked Highways England if they could close the road an hour later.

"It's not Highways England's fault as the game has been scheduled at short notice on a Friday night, but I thought it might make a bit of sense to avoid a whole load of chaos by starting an hour later," he said. "The closure is going to start at 10 o'clock and at about quarter to ten, roughly, there will be about 30,000 other people coming out of the Derby ground. I would expect a chunk of those would normally be heading towards the M1 by car."


It's not just on the railways where significant engineering maintenance / improvement work has to be done, sometime or other.  ::)


A fine example of a major sporting event planned at late notice after traffic infrastructure closure for works has been planned at what was anticipated to be a quiet time.

Common sense comment and request for a start about an hour later from Tom Greatrex. But he's right only to ask (and not demand with indignation) in my view. Criticism may be due to the people who scheduled the match to clash, but even there we don't know if they were aware of / checked for other goings on, how real (an how much of a storm in a teacup this is), and what other constraints there were.

So this numpty wants a project that has more than likely been planned for 2 years, several hundred construction workers and their plant mobilised, local authorities, Police etc made ready; the date of the closure published ....................  ???

For a football match that was planned at the drop of a hat ....................... really  :-\

And this person is supposed to be an MP, I thought they were supposed to be concerned about "public sector" be more efficient like the "private sector" ..................... 

No, he acknowledged that it wasn't a Highways England issue and in his capacity as Chairman of Fulham supporters Trust politely asked if the road could be closed an hour later than planned, not sure how that makes him a "numpty"?

The football match wasn't organised at the "drop of a hat", the playoff semi final had been in the calendar from the start of the season, the teams taking part can't be confirmed till the end of the season

......and he's not an MP - perhaps worth reading the whole article and/or doing a little research  before commencing frothing at the mouth?  :)


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: Surrey 455 on May 13, 2018, 09:06:21
Could the football match kick off an hour earlier?


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: grahame on May 13, 2018, 09:10:21
No, he acknowledged that it wasn't a Highways England issue and in his capacity as Chairman of Fulham supporters Trust politely asked if the road could be closed an hour later than planned, not sure how that makes him a "numpty"?

Agreed - he would have been a numpty to demand ... he's asked a sensible question.  I suspect that the chairman of a team's supporter's trust has little or no influence over the scheduling of matches such as this.

Looking around for potential "numpties" who are making for significant traffic problems, I'm reading of a couple who've chosen to have their high profile wedding next weekend at the end of a branch line that is having to have special measures put in place to cope, when his granny has a big place in central London that's all set up for big events, has excellent transport links and probably will be empty that day.


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: TaplowGreen on May 13, 2018, 09:32:59
No, he acknowledged that it wasn't a Highways England issue and in his capacity as Chairman of Fulham supporters Trust politely asked if the road could be closed an hour later than planned, not sure how that makes him a "numpty"?

Agreed - he would have been a numpty to demand ... he's asked a sensible question.  I suspect that the chairman of a team's supporter's trust has little or no influence over the scheduling of matches such as this.

Looking around for potential "numpties" who are making for significant traffic problems, I'm reading of a couple who've chosen to have their high profile wedding next weekend at the end of a branch line that is having to have special measures put in place to cope, when his granny has a big place in central London that's all set up for big events, has excellent transport links and probably will be empty that day.

I recall watching an interview with a disabled ex serviceman who served with Prince Harry who invited all those who think he is stupid, feckless etc, to serve two tours in Afghanistan, learn to fly an Apache attack helicopter, found and maintain a charity that transforms the lives of the most vulnerable children in Africa, and similarly start a worldwide paralympic multi sport games that does similar for servicemen who have been terribly wounded defending our freedoms, to give similar service and then come back and have the same conversation.

I thought that summed it up pretty well.

I don't think we are yet so churlish as a Nation to try to tell such a man where he should and shouldn't spend the happiest day of his life.

Walk a mile in a man's shoes Graham.

(.....and there are two stations in Windsor by the way!)  ;)



Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: broadgage on May 13, 2018, 12:43:14
Whilst I respect the Royal couple, and agree that they are entitled to hold the wedding where they wish, I feel that London might have been a better choice for such a high profile and popular event.


Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: TaplowGreen on May 13, 2018, 16:43:51
Whilst I respect the Royal couple, and agree that they are entitled to hold the wedding where they wish, I feel that London might have been a better choice for such a high profile and popular event.

I suppose it depends on how you define "better", and from whose perspective?

I struggle to picture an Equerry or similar saying "Sorry Sir, Windsor's a non starter, GWR can only run 3 car trains into Windsor and Eton Central"  :)



Title: Re: M1 diversion: Drivers warned to expect delays over weekend - 12 / 13 May 2018
Post by: broadgage on May 19, 2018, 07:35:09
I doubt that an Equerry would comment in detail on the inadequacy of a particular train service, they are probably not even aware of the details.

I could however see such an advisor suggesting "I feel that a London venue might be a better choice, your Highness. Large numbers of your loyal subjects will no doubt wish to attend, and London is better served by numerous public transport links. For those unable to make the return trip in one day, London also the merit of numerous large hotels" 



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net