Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => The Wider Picture Overseas => Topic started by: Lee on January 26, 2019, 08:34:35



Title: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Lee on January 26, 2019, 08:34:35
Officials say the Solari board has grown obsolete. The removal is part of a modernization plan for the station - https://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/ap/article-6634307/Last-stop-train-stations-flipping-departures-board.html


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Red Squirrel on January 26, 2019, 11:10:10
Did anyone else detect a not-so-subtle bias in that article? The close-up photo shows departures running 3hrs and 90 mins late, whilst the wide shot shows a long list of trains that are 'On time' or 'Boarding'...


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Bmblbzzz on January 31, 2019, 13:24:38
The second photo makes it look as if the board is obscuring the ornate columns (sorry, not sure if they're Corinthian, Ionic or Doric!) but from the third shot it's clear they're not. Anyway, my view is that it's just an information board and if there are now better ways of displaying that information (complying with the ADA) then the best place for fans of old tech to see the board is in a museum.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: grahame on January 31, 2019, 13:38:48
I confess - I'm sad to see the Solari / flipping boards go; I remember seeing them as a new wonder in Euston in - what - the 1960s, with the magic appearance of train as all the leaf sections in a column started to flip and in a handful of seconds most of them had stopped ... others carrying on till the column was complete leaving, magically, a complete train.   And then, as trains departed, the left most column cleared and each of the others moves / flipped up in turn.    I believe they replaced even older punched card / technical systems - vague recollections of those at Victoria, with a wooden walkway along the front, fenced off almost like a church pew in which the team operating the board scurried up and down pulling levels and placing cards to rotate slats showing station names high above to passenger looking for their trains.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: bobm on January 31, 2019, 14:52:37
I can remember watching them flipping over and catching a brief glimpse of a station name where regular services no longer called before settling on the correct information.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Richard Fairhurst on January 31, 2019, 16:15:08
For those with a yen for such things, I built this a good few years ago: http://www.charlbury.info/departures/

It requires Flash so won't work on phones, and indeed most desktop browsers will be sniffy these days. Like the Philly one, it's due to be decommissioned in the next day or so. (I'm moving the Charlbury website to a new server.)

But there do appear to be a few open-source Javascript implementations - grahame, are you tempted to rig one up to your lovely new departure boards here?  ;D


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Red Squirrel on January 31, 2019, 16:45:04
...not sure if they're Corinthian, Ionic or Doric

Emphatically Corinthian.

I'll never forget walking into a London terminus some time in the early 80's, a little later and possibly worse for wear and tear than I should have been, and watching such a board tick a few times and then change from being full of detail that I had not had time to digest to completely and resolutely blank. Quite dispiriting.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: grahame on January 31, 2019, 17:37:55
For those with a yen for such things, I built this a good few years ago: http://www.charlbury.info/departures/

It requires Flash so won't work on phones, and indeed most desktop browsers will be sniffy these days. Like the Philly one, it's due to be decommissioned in the next day or so. (I'm moving the Charlbury website to a new server.)

Good luck with the move

Quote
But there do appear to be a few open-source Javascript implementations - grahame, are you tempted to rig one up to your lovely new departure boards here?  ;D

Tempted ... but Javascript isn't my thing and I don't want to mix up the passenger-useful facilities in a heritage wrapper.  I would be more tempted to chain the departure boards, but really I have too much on my plate for the next three weeks.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: JayMac on January 31, 2019, 17:39:40
Quote
Emphatically Corinthian.

Yes, the column's capitals do suggest Corinthian. Which is a shame for my intended pun.

Isn't it Ionic? So sang Alanis Morrisette.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: stuving on January 31, 2019, 19:40:13
I was thinking about where I've seen any recently, and the obvious answer is France - SNCF made something of a feature of them in their stations, usually up on the wall over the door to the platforms. But I'm struggling to find out how many bigger ones have been removed so far - Montparnasse came down in 2017, St Lazare had a big renovation not long ago and I suspect lost its one, but Gare du Nord may well be there still (someone must have been there last year). I was sure Nantes still had one in September, but I find my memory was wrong again (and it would have gone once the current rebuild is finished anyway).


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Surrey 455 on January 31, 2019, 22:37:51
I confess - I'm sad to see the Solari / flipping boards go; I remember seeing them as a new wonder in Euston in - what - the 1960s, with the magic appearance of train as all the leaf sections in a column started to flip and in a handful of seconds most of them had stopped ... others carrying on till the column was complete leaving, magically, a complete train.   And then, as trains departed, the left most column cleared and each of the others moves / flipped up in turn.    I believe they replaced even older punched card / technical systems - vague recollections of those at Victoria, with a wooden walkway along the front, fenced off almost like a church pew in which the team operating the board scurried up and down pulling levels and placing cards to rotate slats showing station names high above to passenger looking for their trains.

My memories as a youngster were mainly at Heathrow T1 & T2 departures and a vague memory (possibly imagined) at Paddington station.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Reginald25 on February 01, 2019, 07:08:58
I still think the Solari indicators allowed the hurrying commuter a faster appreciation of when the next train to the required destination was running and which platform. I specially remember the board at Paddington when commuting from Reading in the 70s.
That said, the mechanical innards must have been a nightmare (and costly) to maintain, whereas the modern ones are throwaway modules.
Perhaps the NRM should have a section of a display, now they are 'history'.
Incidentally I'm old enough to remember the slot in destination boards at the ticket barrier at Welling, Kent, in the 60s.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Bmblbzzz on February 01, 2019, 08:48:24
It's a shame the linked article didn't say in what way they fail to meet the Americans with Disabilities Act and how the new display will comply. I imagine it might be by providing some sort of audio link for the blind via Bluetooth or wifi, but it might be something else completely. It would also be informative to know if similar facilities are required under UK legislation and how they are provided.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: martyjon on February 01, 2019, 09:40:22
....  Incidentally I'm old enough to remember the slot in destination boards at the ticket barrier at Welling, Kent, in the 60s.

Yea, I remember them too but they were on the platforms at Bristol Temple Meads INCLUDING the blank one where the platform staff would chalk up with the destinations where they didn't have a specific one. I also remember the boards above the carriage windows showing the destinations including the named express title on titled trains.

There was a wooden destinations board at Bath Green Park which sadly was already out of service during my visits to that station and I was surprised at the number of destinations that were served from there besides Bournemouth West.  Broadstone, Templecombe, Evercreech Junction, Bristol Temple Meads, Gloucester Eastgate, Cheltenham Lansdown Road, Birmingham New Street, Manchester Mayfield, Sheffield Midland, Leeds City, Mangotsfield, Clifton Down,  Avonmouth Docks to name a few I remember. I have never found a photograph of the board so if any forum member has one or can point me to a link to one I'd be more than grateful.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: JayMac on February 01, 2019, 13:17:45
Destination/calling point finger boards were in use well into the 1980s at Taunton, and if my memory serves me correctly, in use at Weston-super-Mare into the 21st century.


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: Surrey 455 on February 02, 2019, 10:54:21
Destination/calling point finger boards were in use well into the 1980s at Taunton, and if my memory serves me correctly, in use at Weston-super-Mare into the 21st century.

Also still being used in the early 90s at Ealing Broadway


Title: Re: Last stop for Philadelphia train station's flipping departures board
Post by: JayMac on February 26, 2020, 03:18:02
Solari boards have also largely disappeared from airports too. One survivor, at Singapore Changhi Airport, is being decommissioned today, 26th February 2020.

News report, including video footage of the board on operation:

BBC News - Solari boards: The disappearing sound of airports
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-51470599





This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net