Great Western Coffee Shop

All across the Great Western territory => The Wider Picture in the United Kingdom => Topic started by: grahame on August 22, 2020, 06:35:52



Title: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on August 22, 2020, 06:35:52
Encouraged by an early morning headline, I followed up what's running on Eurostar - testing prices and times by looking at a trip outbound middle of next week, back a week later.

4 direct services each way to / from Paris
2 direct services each way to / from Brussels
1 direct service to Amsterdam

"Top of site" says nothing from Ebbsfleet or Ashford at present ... booking engine allows you to try but flags up "Sorry, there are no seats left on trains going out that day. Can you travel on another date?"

Outbound fares, Paris ... from £89.50 next week. Return from £39.00 the week after -  2 hr 17 min to 2 hour 26 min journey time.

Outbound fares, Brussels ... from £74.50 next week. Return from £44.50 the week after -  2 hr 1 min to 2 hour 20 min journey time.

Outbound fares, Amsterdam, ... from £75.00 next week. Return from £119.50 the week after -  4 hr 7 journey time outbound.   Return journey time 5 hr 50 mins including 1 hour 44 minutes to change trains in Brussels.

Business premier tickets at £245.00 each way to Paris or Brussels ... £260.00 out, £329.35 return for Amsterdam.

From the Eurostar site - background travel information:

Quote
IMPORTANT INFORMATION: Before you book, please note that we’ve adapted our services to help keep you safe at this time.

BUSINESS PREMIER: You have full flexibility to change your travel plans. Your ticket is fully refundable and can be exchanged as many times as you want. Our Business Premier lounges are all now open again. The way we serve food and drink has changed and social distancing measures will be in place. Our fast track ticket gates are also open again.

BUSINESS PREMIER AND STANDARD PREMIER CATERING: We’re currently unable to serve food and drink on board. Our catering services will resume on 7 September 2020.

ALL PASSENGERS: ALL passengers are required to complete COVID-19 mandatory government forms and check latest government info before travelling as quarantine rules may apply at short notice. You must check our Coronavirus Essential Travel information here. Please be aware that official advice may change quickly so it’s important to keep up-to-date.

Our onboard bar buffet is closed until 7 September 2020 and many of the shops and restaurants at our stations are also closed. Please bring refreshments with you, especially when the weather gets warm. You can bring liquids through security.

We’re sorry for the inconvenience caused.

That "here" link takes you to

Quote
Coronavirus and Eurostar services – updated 21 August 2020

Check this page for all the latest and Essential COVID-19 Travel Information

Our main priority is the health and wellbeing of our customers and colleagues. We’re closely following advice from governments and health authorities in our destination countries, regarding Coronavirus (COVID-19). We are listening closely to the feedback of our customers and colleagues and we realise this is an unsettling time and an unprecedented situation that develops fast.

IMPORTANT: We advise all passengers to regularly check latest official government information of their country of origin and destination prior to departure. Special measures or quarantine rules may apply at short notice so it’s important to keep up-to-date.

If you’ve emailed us or submitted an eVoucher request and received an automated reply, please rest assured we will get back to you and your eVoucher will be sent to you soon. Our teams are working tirelessly and doing their best to respond to thousands of calls and emails as quickly as possible. Don't worry if your travel dates have already passed, we'll still be able to issue your eVoucher as normal.

Thank you for your patience and understanding, and for showing our colleagues the respect they deserve at a difficult time for everyone.

In addition, current requirement is [check, please] for passengers travelling from France or Belgium to self-isolate for 14 days, with certain exceptions.  Should that not appear somewhere in the text above?


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on August 22, 2020, 07:44:02
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

There is also, despite Ashford having the platforms remodelled and the French signalling installed there is a technical problem with the electrification (AC/DC interface) which prevents the Class 374 (Siemens trains) from using Ashford, this is being resolved but was not planned for completion until the end of this year.  I suspect the Eurostar have mothballed the remaining Class 373 (original Eurostar) as they are expensive to maintain.

It will be interesting to see if Ebbsfleet and Ashford ever see Eurostar services again, although Kent CC and Ashford Council have invested a lot of money into Ashford to allow the 374 to use Ashford so there may be a lot of political pressure.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on December 19, 2020, 14:44:36
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

From The London Economic (https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/french-officials-to-patrol-eurostar-trains-amid-brexit-customs-chaos/19/12/)

Quote
France will deploy customs officers to patrol Eurostar trains from London to Paris when the UK's Brexit transition ends on 31 December, reports suggest.

With Channel ports already clogged up by lengthy traffic jams, Paris feels compelled to introduce the drastic on-train checks ? because UK and French authorities are yet to agree post-Brexit customs controls.

"There?s a discussion under way between the French and British authorities to allow French customs to have an official presence on British soil at points of embarkation," Olivier Dussopt ? the French customs minister ? told the Financial Times.

French officials are reportedly surprised at the administrative "mess" and lack of preparation on the English side of the Channel, the paper reported.

Oh dear ... my understanding is that Eurostar's traffic has been decimated far more than any other TOC already by Coronavirus


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Bmblbzzz on December 19, 2020, 17:18:14
I'm pretty sure this is standard practice on cross-border trains where there is no suitable border station. The customs and passport authorities of both countries in effect circulate between the two stations nearest the border. The alternative is that, where there's a suitable station near the border (or even if a site gets built specially at the border), formalities are completed while the train is stationary, either with passengers leaving the carriages and passing through a terminal, or with border agents walking through the train. Doing these on-board while the train is in motion obviously avoids delays and so is probably preferable.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Robin Summerhill on December 19, 2020, 21:46:35
I'm pretty sure this is standard practice on cross-border trains where there is no suitable border station. The customs and passport authorities of both countries in effect circulate between the two stations nearest the border. The alternative is that, where there's a suitable station near the border (or even if a site gets built specially at the border), formalities are completed while the train is stationary, either with passengers leaving the carriages and passing through a terminal, or with border agents walking through the train. Doing these on-board while the train is in motion obviously avoids delays and so is probably preferable.

Precise arrangements may well depend on the relationship between the two countries concerned as well. On board passport checks certainly happened between France and Belgium in the early 1970s (the last time I crossed that border by train), whilst at the same time customs formalities between France and Switzerland were carried out when the trains arrived at Basel.

I never actually travelled the route, but when the line from Western Europe to Istanbul crossed briefly into Greece at Erdine I am told that there were "difficulties" due to the general animosity between Greece and Turkey that has lasted for hundreds of years

 


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on December 19, 2020, 21:50:07
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

From The London Economic (https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/french-officials-to-patrol-eurostar-trains-amid-brexit-customs-chaos/19/12/)

Quote
France will deploy customs officers to patrol Eurostar trains from London to Paris when the UK's Brexit transition ends on 31 December, reports suggest.

With Channel ports already clogged up by lengthy traffic jams, Paris feels compelled to introduce the drastic on-train checks ? because UK and French authorities are yet to agree post-Brexit customs controls.

"There?s a discussion under way between the French and British authorities to allow French customs to have an official presence on British soil at points of embarkation," Olivier Dussopt ? the French customs minister ? told the Financial Times.

French officials are reportedly surprised at the administrative "mess" and lack of preparation on the English side of the Channel, the paper reported.

Oh dear ... my understanding is that Eurostar's traffic has been decimated far more than any other TOC already by Coronavirus
I'm pretty sure this is standard practice on cross-border trains where there is no suitable border station. The customs and passport authorities of both countries in effect circulate between the two stations nearest the border. The alternative is that, where there's a suitable station near the border (or even if a site gets built specially at the border), formalities are completed while the train is stationary, either with passengers leaving the carriages and passing through a terminal, or with border agents walking through the train. Doing these on-board while the train is in motion obviously avoids delays and so is probably preferable.

It is but ................. the UK Government has not been very good at dealing with us leaving the EU ................ I am convinced the UK Government holds the belief that the EU would copulate and give us a free trade agreement on our terms.   Now the Dove / Folkestone corner of Kent is going to be in chaos for weeks, even worse if it snows.

When the PM deploys the gun ships to protect the UK fishing waters, the French fishermen will blockage to French ports

Good thing the SE of the UK is in Tier 4  

  


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TaplowGreen on December 19, 2020, 22:11:16
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

From The London Economic (https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/french-officials-to-patrol-eurostar-trains-amid-brexit-customs-chaos/19/12/)

Quote
France will deploy customs officers to patrol Eurostar trains from London to Paris when the UK's Brexit transition ends on 31 December, reports suggest.

With Channel ports already clogged up by lengthy traffic jams, Paris feels compelled to introduce the drastic on-train checks ? because UK and French authorities are yet to agree post-Brexit customs controls.

"There?s a discussion under way between the French and British authorities to allow French customs to have an official presence on British soil at points of embarkation," Olivier Dussopt ? the French customs minister ? told the Financial Times.

French officials are reportedly surprised at the administrative "mess" and lack of preparation on the English side of the Channel, the paper reported.

Oh dear ... my understanding is that Eurostar's traffic has been decimated far more than any other TOC already by Coronavirus
I'm pretty sure this is standard practice on cross-border trains where there is no suitable border station. The customs and passport authorities of both countries in effect circulate between the two stations nearest the border. The alternative is that, where there's a suitable station near the border (or even if a site gets built specially at the border), formalities are completed while the train is stationary, either with passengers leaving the carriages and passing through a terminal, or with border agents walking through the train. Doing these on-board while the train is in motion obviously avoids delays and so is probably preferable.

It is but ................. the UK Government has not been very good at dealing with us leaving the EU ................ I am convinced the UK Government holds the belief that the EU would copulate and give us a free trade agreement on our terms.   Now the Dove / Folkestone corner of Kent is going to be in chaos for weeks, even worse if it snows.

When the PM deploys the gun ships to protect the UK fishing waters, the French fishermen will blockage to French ports

Good thing the SE of the UK is in Tier 4  

  

......I wasn't aware that copulation was on the agenda as part of the negotiations, but with Boris around, you never know! 🙂


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on December 19, 2020, 22:53:39

......I wasn't aware that copulation was on the agenda as part of the negotiations, but with Boris around, you never know! 🙂

It is all a bit of a copulating mess ........... but I hate to think what state we would be in if without his oven ready deal :D


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Bmblbzzz on December 19, 2020, 23:07:28
I'm pretty sure this is standard practice on cross-border trains where there is no suitable border station. The customs and passport authorities of both countries in effect circulate between the two stations nearest the border. The alternative is that, where there's a suitable station near the border (or even if a site gets built specially at the border), formalities are completed while the train is stationary, either with passengers leaving the carriages and passing through a terminal, or with border agents walking through the train. Doing these on-board while the train is in motion obviously avoids delays and so is probably preferable.

Precise arrangements may well depend on the relationship between the two countries concerned as well. On board passport checks certainly happened between France and Belgium in the early 1970s (the last time I crossed that border by train), whilst at the same time customs formalities between France and Switzerland were carried out when the trains arrived at Basel.

I never actually travelled the route, but when the line from Western Europe to Istanbul crossed briefly into Greece at Erdine I am told that there were "difficulties" due to the general animosity between Greece and Turkey that has lasted for hundreds of years

 
Yes, definitely. As ET points out, there's plenty of scope for things going wrong in other areas to affect this too. But at the same time, I remember that UK passport control is or certainly used to be carried out in Calais and other French ferry ports, before boarding.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: stuving on December 19, 2020, 23:45:37
You may remember from the news that on the 10th December the EU (not just the Commission) issue a statement on contingency measures to prevent everything lurching to a halt on 1st January in the absence of a Brexit agreement. This document (https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/communication-commission-limited-contingency-measures-absence-agreement-future-partnership-united-kingdom) contained a section (in the main statement, not an Annex) on the tunnel (there are others on aviation etc.):
Quote
4.3 The railway connection through the Channel Tunnel

In the absence of a Union contingency measure, the operation of the Channel Fixed Link through the Channel Tunnel would need to be suspended after the end of the transition period. In such a case, trains would not be able to circulate through the Channel Tunnel connecting the United Kingdom with the European continent.

In light of the economic importance to the Union of the Channel Fixed Link, the Commission adopted, on 27 November, a proposal for a Regulation that would ensure that the Channel Fixed Link continues to operate after 1 January 2021, until other arrangements have been put in place.

The operation of the Channel Fixed Link through the Channel Tunnel is supervised by an Intergovernmental Commission (the ?IGC?), established by the Treaty of Canterbury between the French Republic and the United Kingdom signed on 12 February 1986. Until the end of the transition period, the IGC is recognised as a national safety authority entrusted by two Member States with ensuring that Union safety and interoperability rules apply to the whole Channel Tunnel. It issues relevant safety certificates and authorisations.

France has been empowered to negotiate, sign and conclude an international agreement with the United Kingdom in order to maintain a unified safety regime and the IGC. However, an agreement will not have entered into force at the end of the transition period. Without such an agreement, as from 1 January 2021, the IGC no longer qualifies as national safety authority under EU law and the certificates and authorisations it has issued lose their validity.

The proposed Regulation would extend the validity of authorisations issued by the IGC for a period of two months. This would give enough time for the French national safety authority to take over the supervision and issue its own certificates.

In order to ensure connectivity between the Union and the United Kingdom, it is also essential that the rail operators providing services in the Tunnel continue to do so and can reach the border-crossing station of Calais-Fr?thun. To that end, the period of validity of their licenses issued by the United Kingdom and of their safety certificates issued by the Intergovernmental Commission should be extended for a period of nine months. This extension would give enough time for the negotiation and conclusion of the necessary arrangements foreseen in Union law to avoid disruptions.

I found that rather odd. I understood that the intergovernmental treaty regulating the tunnel, when signed, didn't depend on the EEC/EU or its laws, but did the usual traditional things about borders. The actual "land" border is at the half-way point, an  inconvenient place to stop trains for immigration and customs formalities. The treaty set up joint institutions to allow such things (not just safety) to be managed jointly. While everything crossing that border will be affected by Brexit, I don't see why the border itself and its treaty would need changing, as opposed to (ideally) having an agreement on top.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on December 20, 2020, 08:05:06
You may remember from the news that on the 10th December the EU (not just the Commission) issue a statement on contingency measures to prevent everything lurching to a halt on 1st January in the absence of a Brexit agreement. This document (https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/communication-commission-limited-contingency-measures-absence-agreement-future-partnership-united-kingdom) contained a section (in the main statement, not an Annex) on the tunnel (there are others on aviation etc.):
Quote
4.3 The railway connection through the Channel Tunnel

In the absence of a Union contingency measure, the operation of the Channel Fixed Link through the Channel Tunnel would need to be suspended after the end of the transition period. In such a case, trains would not be able to circulate through the Channel Tunnel connecting the United Kingdom with the European continent.

In light of the economic importance to the Union of the Channel Fixed Link, the Commission adopted, on 27 November, a proposal for a Regulation that would ensure that the Channel Fixed Link continues to operate after 1 January 2021, until other arrangements have been put in place.

The operation of the Channel Fixed Link through the Channel Tunnel is supervised by an Intergovernmental Commission (the ?IGC?), established by the Treaty of Canterbury between the French Republic and the United Kingdom signed on 12 February 1986. Until the end of the transition period, the IGC is recognised as a national safety authority entrusted by two Member States with ensuring that Union safety and interoperability rules apply to the whole Channel Tunnel. It issues relevant safety certificates and authorisations.

France has been empowered to negotiate, sign and conclude an international agreement with the United Kingdom in order to maintain a unified safety regime and the IGC. However, an agreement will not have entered into force at the end of the transition period. Without such an agreement, as from 1 January 2021, the IGC no longer qualifies as national safety authority under EU law and the certificates and authorisations it has issued lose their validity.

The proposed Regulation would extend the validity of authorisations issued by the IGC for a period of two months. This would give enough time for the French national safety authority to take over the supervision and issue its own certificates.

In order to ensure connectivity between the Union and the United Kingdom, it is also essential that the rail operators providing services in the Tunnel continue to do so and can reach the border-crossing station of Calais-Fr?thun. To that end, the period of validity of their licenses issued by the United Kingdom and of their safety certificates issued by the Intergovernmental Commission should be extended for a period of nine months. This extension would give enough time for the negotiation and conclusion of the necessary arrangements foreseen in Union law to avoid disruptions.

I found that rather odd. I understood that the intergovernmental treaty regulating the tunnel, when signed, didn't depend on the EEC/EU or its laws, but did the usual traditional things about borders. The actual "land" border is at the half-way point, an  inconvenient place to stop trains for immigration and customs formalities. The treaty set up joint institutions to allow such things (not just safety) to be managed jointly. While everything crossing that border will be affected by Brexit, I don't see why the border itself and its treaty would need changing, as opposed to (ideally) having an agreement on top.


Regards Eurostars it is relatively simple as this service is about the movement of people and not goods, although people can still transport items this a small scale.   Customs checks are not so critical and is something that can be done on board the train, its a 2 hour journey. 

Eurotunnels fixed rail link is however a different matter its core business is the transport of goods checking manifests on a 40 min journey is not practical, the M20 Operation Stack and even the return of Operation Brock.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: ChrisB on December 20, 2020, 16:43:26
Belgium has banned flights & Eurostar services from midnight tonight


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on December 20, 2020, 17:30:04
Belgium has banned flights & Eurostar services from midnight tonight
The Netherlands has banned UK flights, Germany, Italy and France are likely follow suit, so expect Eurostars to cease altogether


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyK on December 21, 2020, 10:15:32
I never actually travelled the route, but when the line from Western Europe to Istanbul crossed briefly into Greece at Erdine I am told that there were "difficulties" due to the general animosity between Greece and Turkey that has lasted for hundreds of years.

Since 1923, officially.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: eightonedee on December 21, 2020, 12:17:42
Quote
.......... but I hate to think what state we would be in if without his oven ready deal

Perhaps he misspoke (again?) - it might have only been "shovel ready".... ;)


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Robin Summerhill on December 21, 2020, 16:00:48
Quote
.......... but I hate to think what state we would be in if without his oven ready deal

Perhaps he misspoke (again?) - it might have only been "shovel ready".... ;)

I know what sort of shovel Im thinking of. What sort of shovel are you thinking of?

;)


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: stuving on December 21, 2020, 16:19:21
Stopping cross-channel transport cuts both ways of course. There's a lot of French living over here, mostly in London, and many of them (notably the younger/single ones) were planning to go home for a family Christmas (Eve). I've heard a figure of 40,000 mentioned, though that sounds a bit much for capacity. A lot of them are trying to work out how to get a PCR test done, as the announced plan is that one will be required under the new rules starting on Wednesday.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on February 03, 2021, 21:28:27
From City a.m. (https://www.cityam.com/eurostar-is-not-our-company-to-rescue-says-grant-shapps/)

Quote
The transport secretary has poured cold water on hopes that the UK would lead the rescue of the struggling Eurostar rail link.

Speaking to MPs on the Transport Select Committee this morning, Grant Shapps said that the cross-channel service was “not our company to rescue”.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyK on February 04, 2021, 11:22:18
From City a.m. (https://www.cityam.com/eurostar-is-not-our-company-to-rescue-says-grant-shapps/)

Quote
The transport secretary has poured cold water on hopes that the UK would lead the rescue of the struggling Eurostar rail link.

Speaking to MPs on the Transport Select Committee this morning, Grant Shapps said that the cross-channel service was “not our company to rescue”.

The minister is correct. Eurostar is now owned by Eurostar International Ltd.  EIL is owned by SNCF (55%, France), Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ) (30%, Canada), Hermes Infrastructure (10%, USA) and NMBS/SNCB (5%, Belgium). The tunnel itself is owned by Getlink. I think the UK has successfully washed its hands of that, too, although so much has changed since the original company was formed that it is hard to tell.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: eightonedee on February 04, 2021, 13:57:35
Quote
The minister is correct. Eurostar is now owned by Eurostar International Ltd.  EIL is owned by SNCF (55%, France), Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ) (30%, Canada), Hermes Infrastructure (10%, USA) and NMBS/SNCB (5%, Belgium). The tunnel itself is owned by Getlink. I think the UK has successfully washed its hands of that, too, although so much has changed since the original company was formed that it is hard to tell.

At one level that is correct, but at another level it is also part of UK plc's infrastructure. That's what neither the right wing privatise it all brigade nor the left wing nationalise it all brigade understand. A government has responsibilities that go beyond "is it a state asset?", and owners of infrastructure have to remember that they have responsibilities (often written into legislation, but going beyond this) to the society for whom they are providing the relevant services.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyK on February 04, 2021, 14:25:02

At one level that is correct, but at another level it is also part of UK plc's infrastructure. That's what neither the right wing privatise it all brigade nor the left wing nationalise it all brigade understand. A government has responsibilities that go beyond "is it a state asset?", and owners of infrastructure have to remember that they have responsibilities (often written into legislation, but going beyond this) to the society for whom they are providing the relevant services.

The inevitable compromise may reflect that, but the government here will insist that the owners bear the financial burden until that can be taken no further. I am sure that the minister will "work closely with them"* to ensure that they can speedily resume their commercial activities.

(*Translation: "You're on your own, let us know when you've sorted it.")


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on February 04, 2021, 14:33:03
Quote
The minister is correct. Eurostar is now owned by Eurostar International Ltd.  EIL is owned by SNCF (55%, France), Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ) (30%, Canada), Hermes Infrastructure (10%, USA) and NMBS/SNCB (5%, Belgium). The tunnel itself is owned by Getlink. I think the UK has successfully washed its hands of that, too, although so much has changed since the original company was formed that it is hard to tell.

At one level that is correct, but at another level it is also part of UK plc's infrastructure. That's what neither the right wing privatise it all brigade nor the left wing nationalise it all brigade understand. A government has responsibilities that go beyond "is it a state asset?", and owners of infrastructure have to remember that they have responsibilities (often written into legislation, but going beyond this) to the society for whom they are providing the relevant services.

Can I clarify?   The tunnel is owned by Getlink who also operate Le Shuttle through it.  They receive an income from Eurostar who pay to run their passenger trains through.  So a failure of Eurostar would not close the tunnel - just limit it to shuttle trains and freight (Db run this!).  Shuttle trains can take coaches, and another operator could run passenger trains too.

So - if Eurostar fails, someone else can have a go??


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyK on February 04, 2021, 14:49:45

Can I clarify?   The tunnel is owned by Getlink who also operate Le Shuttle through it.  They receive an income from Eurostar who pay to run their passenger trains through.  So a failure of Eurostar would not close the tunnel - just limit it to shuttle trains and freight (Db run this!).  Shuttle trains can take coaches, and another operator could run passenger trains too.

So - if Eurostar fails, someone else can have a go??

One would assume so, although I would imagine that the bureaucracy behind such a move would be quite daunting for a private operator. Maybe Go-op could come up with a plan?


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: patch38 on February 04, 2021, 14:50:37

So - if Eurostar fails, someone else can have a go??

Slightly unfair on Eurostar: it's unlikely that another operator would do any better in the present circumstances.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on February 04, 2021, 15:05:34

So - if Eurostar fails, someone else can have a go??

Slightly unfair on Eurostar: it's unlikely that another operator would do any better in the present circumstances.

Maybe - perhaps I was playing Devil's advocate.   But the logical extension is that if it's a commercial operation set up to make a profit, and doesn't, then either someone else could try, or could try something else.  Or perhaps there's no case for such services any more now with the different relationship between the UK and mainland Europe?   Still playing Devil's advocate ...


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyN on February 04, 2021, 15:55:27
Quote
Maybe Go-op could come up with a plan?

Well D Stock is designed to be used in tunnels.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: stuving on February 04, 2021, 17:16:57
The construction and legal status of the tunnel is governed by the bilateral Treaty of Canterbury (1986) (http://www.channeltunneligc.co.uk/spip.php?action=acceder_document&arg=93&cle=939ac28402cdf20e06d641b2ef2d1ece&file=pdf%2FTreaty_of_Canterbury_1986.pdf). This doesn't make clear whether "operation" includes running the shuttle trains, but I think it does. In any case everything not in the treaty is a matter for the  Intergovernmental Commission (https://www.channeltunneligc.co.uk/-Who-we-are-.html?lang=en), including the revision of the protocols that extend the treaty. Some aspects of train services and the companies operating them do get considered, though it's not clear which.

Safety is the biggest issue for the IGC, but any matter calling for joint action (or inaction) has to come here too. There are some short minutes of meetings (https://www.channeltunneligc.co.uk/-Ongoing-affairs-.html?lang=en), but not of last one due in December. No doubt adaptations needed for Brexit have been keeping them busy; a new agreement between the ORR and the EPSF (https://www.channeltunneligc.co.uk/spip.php?action=acceder_document&arg=557&cle=02832b777c0cbe941f960bd442211437&file=pdf%2FCooperation_agreement_ORR_-_EPSF_-_IGC_-_7_January_2021.pdf) (their oppos) was published a few days ago.

Labour regulations is one matter for which a protocol is specified in the treaty, but while the minutes of the last meeting (https://www.channeltunneligc.co.uk/spip.php?action=acceder_document&arg=542&cle=5ac7eca21c8685f303e2c69dfbb05668&file=pdf%2F2020_10_08_IGC_website_summary.pdf) note that Eurostar have made use of furlough provisions, that protocol is not mentioned. Presumably any other support would be discussed first in the IGC, but after that ...


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on February 04, 2021, 17:58:40

So - if Eurostar fails, someone else can have a go??

Slightly unfair on Eurostar: it's unlikely that another operator would do any better in the present circumstances.

Maybe - perhaps I was playing Devil's advocate.   But the logical extension is that if it's a commercial operation set up to make a profit, and doesn't, then either someone else could try, or could try something else.  Or perhaps there's no case for such services any more now with the different relationship between the UK and mainland Europe?   Still playing Devil's advocate ...

It is the fire and other safety regulations that have dissuaded other operators like DB, also BREXIT added to DB decision.

Let face it with the current government's anti Europe position they are not likely to assist with anything that links us with Europe


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TonyK on February 04, 2021, 20:21:07
Let face it with the current government's anti Europe position they are not likely to assist with anything that links us with Europe

Au contraire. Mainland Europe will still be a major source of our trade, both ways, once we have reached a compromise. It's just that our government isn't likely to start throwing money at offshore companies operating largely outside of the UK. I am sure that everything possible will be done to facilitate a proper resumption of traffic, short of payments. We could, for example, agree to turn a blind eye to generous state aid in the sector.

Remember that in the UK, much of our railway is operated by state-owned companies. Just not our state.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on August 26, 2022, 06:06:51
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

From Rail Magazine (https://www.railmagazine.com/news/network/2022/08/25/eurostar-confirms-extended-absence-from-kent-stations)

Quote
Eurostar services will not call at either Ebbsfleet or Ashford International station during 2023, the cross-channel operator has confirmed.

Both HS1 stations were shut at the beginning of the Coronavirus pandemic, with the company announcing last year that they would not reopen until 2023 at the earliest.

A Eurostar spokesman blamed “an uncertain and fragile environment” for the continued closure, citing COVID-19 and Brexit as heavily influencing the latest decision.

I wonder if Eurostar will ever call at Ebbsfleet or Ashford again - are Covid and Brexit convenient reasons given for them to give up something that from a business viewpoint had become a bit of an unprofitable nuisance to them?


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Timmer on August 26, 2022, 06:23:47
From Rail Magazine (https://www.railmagazine.com/news/network/2022/08/25/eurostar-confirms-extended-absence-from-kent-stations)

Quote
Eurostar services will not call at either Ebbsfleet or Ashford International station during 2023, the cross-channel operator has confirmed.

Both HS1 stations were shut at the beginning of the Coronavirus pandemic, with the company announcing last year that they would not reopen until 2023 at the earliest.

A Eurostar spokesman blamed “an uncertain and fragile environment” for the continued closure, citing COVID-19 and Brexit as heavily influencing the latest decision.

I wonder if Eurostar will ever call at Ebbsfleet or Ashford again - are Covid and Brexit convenient reasons given for them to give up something that from a business viewpoint had become a bit of an unprofitable nuisance to them?


BBC reported the other day that it may not be until 2025:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-62647504

Quote
Eurostar has announced its services may not stop in Kent again until 2025.
The company's trains have not called at Ashford or Ebbsfleet since March 2020, due to the coronavirus pandemic.

The operator said it understood this would be disappointing for local communities.
Ashford Borough Council's leader described the decision as a "real challenge" for the community and said he would continue to push for services to be resumed.

Eurostar confirmed services carrying passengers between London St Pancras and Europe via the Channel Tunnel would not stop at the two Kent stations during 2023.

It added it would not be able to "make any commitment for another two to three years".
Eurostar cited financial factors and the post-Brexit border situation, with the EU's entry/exit system due to be in place by the end of May 2023 expected to add "further complexity".
Continues…


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: TaplowGreen on August 30, 2022, 18:41:46
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-62728618.amp

Stopping services to Disneyland Paris too.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: IndustryInsider on August 30, 2022, 20:48:19
Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on August 31, 2022, 06:31:10
There are 2 a couple of possible reasons for not stopping at Ebbsfleet and Ashford, UK Boarder Force may have redeployed there staff to other duties also the France may have reduced its staff levels added to the fact that passenger levels at both these stations is not high at the best of times.

From Rail Magazine (https://www.railmagazine.com/news/network/2022/08/25/eurostar-confirms-extended-absence-from-kent-stations)

Quote
Eurostar services will not call at either Ebbsfleet or Ashford International station during 2023, the cross-channel operator has confirmed.

Both HS1 stations were shut at the beginning of the Coronavirus pandemic, with the company announcing last year that they would not reopen until 2023 at the earliest.

A Eurostar spokesman blamed “an uncertain and fragile environment” for the continued closure, citing COVID-19 and Brexit as heavily influencing the latest decision.

I wonder if Eurostar will ever call at Ebbsfleet or Ashford again - are Covid and Brexit convenient reasons given for them to give up something that from a business viewpoint had become a bit of an unprofitable nuisance to them?


There will be 'political' pressure from KCC and Ashford DC to have at Eurostar services stop at Ashford, however as II says

Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.

The UK Government refused to assist Eurostar or Eurotunnel during the lockdowns because they were not UK based companies, both of them were on their knees almost on the point of total collapse.   Eurostar will not be receptive to political pressure from the UK Government or local authorities.

Eurostar has to pay all the security, Border Force etc costs at all 3 UK stations, the UK Government to not provide any finance towards these costs.  Basically, if Eurostar do not believe there is sufficient revenue at Ashford and Ebbsfleet then it makes no business sense to use the stations.

Euro Disney again may be down to UK Boarder control costs at Euro Disney.

The UK Boarder Control costs is just not UK Boarder Force staff but is also Frontex costs.

I suspect the Ski specials may be next for the chop!


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Bmblbzzz on August 31, 2022, 08:21:30
Quote
Eurostar has to pay all the security, Border Force etc costs at all 3 UK stations, the UK Government to not provide any finance towards these costs.
Surprised to learn this. Do similar arrangements apply at ferry and air ports?


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: jamestheredengine on August 31, 2022, 16:12:53
Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.
So fully private that Eurostar is 55% owned by the French state railway, 30% by the Quebec civil service pension scheme, 5% by the Belgian state railway, and only 10% by an American asset management fund. Sounds 90% foreign public sector to me. Not really sure why we're continuing to allow their trains between Ashford International and London St Pancras really – proposing suspending their trackage rights would certainly be an interesting version of playing hard ball with intransigent Gallic bureaucrats to make them pay for their railway company's obligations. If they only want to pay for one border station, then fine, their trains can terminate at Ashford and stop disrupting what should be a regular clockface timetable on the South Eastern.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on August 31, 2022, 18:01:05
Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.
So fully private that Eurostar is 55% owned by the French state railway, 30% by the Quebec civil service pension scheme, 5% by the Belgian state railway, and only 10% by an American asset management fund. Sounds 90% foreign public sector to me. Not really sure why we're continuing to allow their trains between Ashford International and London St Pancras really – proposing suspending their trackage rights would certainly be an interesting version of playing hard ball with intransigent Gallic bureaucrats to make them pay for their railway company's obligations. If they only want to pay for one border station, then fine, their trains can terminate at Ashford and stop disrupting what should be a regular clockface timetable on the South Eastern.

Difficult to do when Highspeed 1 is privately owned, in July 2017, HS1 Ltd was acquired by a consortium comprising of funds advised and managed by InfraRed Capital Partners Limited and Equitix Investment Management Limited.HS1 Ltd has the 30-year concession to own, operate and maintain High Speed 1 (HS1), the UK’s only high-speed railway, as well as the stations along the route: St Pancras International, Stratford International, Ebbsfleet International and Ashford International.
Network Rail Highspeed are the maintenance contractor employed by HS1 Ltd


Quote
Eurostar has to pay all the security, Border Force etc costs at all 3 UK stations, the UK Government to not provide any finance towards these costs.
Surprised to learn this. Do similar arrangements apply at ferry and air ports?

Yes, the Port Authority pay the cost


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Bmblbzzz on August 31, 2022, 19:03:41

Quote
Eurostar has to pay all the security, Border Force etc costs at all 3 UK stations, the UK Government to not provide any finance towards these costs.
Surprised to learn this. Do similar arrangements apply at ferry and air ports?

Yes, the Port Authority pay the cost
I see, thanks.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: IndustryInsider on September 01, 2022, 15:46:29
Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.
So fully private that Eurostar is 55% owned by the French state railway, 30% by the Quebec civil service pension scheme, 5% by the Belgian state railway, and only 10% by an American asset management fund. Sounds 90% foreign public sector to me. Not really sure why we're continuing to allow their trains between Ashford International and London St Pancras really – proposing suspending their trackage rights would certainly be an interesting version of playing hard ball with intransigent Gallic bureaucrats to make them pay for their railway company's obligations. If they only want to pay for one border station, then fine, their trains can terminate at Ashford and stop disrupting what should be a regular clockface timetable on the South Eastern.

Fair enough.  I guess I meant to say fully private in that the DfT has no say in what it runs and doesn’t run and where it stops.


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on September 02, 2022, 06:27:58
Such are the perils of a fully private operation and the complications of Brexit.
If they only want to pay for one border station, then fine, their trains can terminate at Ashford and stop disrupting what should be a regular clockface timetable on the South Eastern.

More often than not its SE Trains that are running late


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Bmblbzzz on October 04, 2022, 14:20:57
Letter from CEO of Eurostar to the Transport Select Committee setting out the difficulties the company is facing and why it cannot reopen Kent services.
https://twitter.com/EurostarJustinp/status/1574711574337495041


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: bobm on October 04, 2022, 14:52:50
I wonder if Eurostar will ever call at Ebbsfleet or Ashford again?

..and if so how long before both stations drop their International suffix?


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: Electric train on October 04, 2022, 15:58:35
Letter from CEO of Eurostar to the Transport Select Committee setting out the difficulties the company is facing and why it cannot reopen Kent services.
https://twitter.com/EurostarJustinp/status/1574711574337495041


I think the Eurostar CEO is politely saying to the Select Committee and UK Government "you have brought much of this on yourselves" by not providing the UK Government backed loans and as for the Regulator, I assume the ORR, dragging in the sand that is shameful.

The UK would appear to be an expensive place to operate, Eurostar Yellow is small in comparison the Eurostar Red (Thalys).

I fully understand the CEO's point about Boarder controls the Eurostar and La Shuttle were designed and built with freedom of movement in mind the concept of a hard Boarder was possibly not considered


Title: Re: Eurostar - snapshot of current services
Post by: grahame on January 25, 2023, 07:37:32
From the BBC (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-64390979)

Quote
The boss of Eurostar has said its trains between the UK and Paris are carrying 30% fewer passengers.

Chief executive Gwendoline Cazenave said with post-Brexit border checks and current levels of border staff, there were "bottlenecks" in stations.

Eurostar is currently running 14 services per day between London and Paris, compared with 18 in 2019.

Ms Cazenave said the company might not restore some services suspended last year due to the problems.

"The thing is now we are not able to run the same transport offer as what we had before in 2019, because of bottlenecks in stations," she said.

"We have a main issue in Eurostar terminals because of the new boarding conditions between the UK and EU, because of the impact of Covid, because of staff in the stations."

From my experience last autumn, Eurostar services and lounges were extremely busy on the service level being operated with the main issue being queues at physical security / scanners, not all of which were in use even on trains that were sold out.  Whilst there is extra processing, I wonder if it suits Eurostar's business model to have a product that's got some scarcity value and run fewer trains than they could at average seat prices above what the average would be if they were running more services.



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net