Great Western Coffee Shop

Journey by Journey => Shorter journeys in Devon => Topic started by: PhilWakely on January 23, 2022, 14:01:01



Title: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: PhilWakely on January 23, 2022, 14:01:01
Quote from: 'RPI' on RailUK forums
From May 2022 I believe there are two GWR services per day between Exeter and Axminster, extension of Barnstaple services, one morning peak and one evening. Crew have been told they'll be route learning soon which is where I've heard it. Though they all learnt to Pinhoe last year and that didn't happen.

Sounds reasonable given the loss of the two SWR 'locals' in the evening Peak and the crush loading of 1L93 (0610 Salisbury to Exeter St Davids) in the morning.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: RichardB on January 23, 2022, 15:53:46
Quote from: 'RPI' on RailUK forums
From May 2022 I believe there are two GWR services per day between Exeter and Axminster, extension of Barnstaple services, one morning peak and one evening. Crew have been told they'll be route learning soon which is where I've heard it. Though they all learnt to Pinhoe last year and that didn't happen.

Sounds reasonable given the loss of the two SWR 'locals' in the evening Peak and the crush loading of 1L93 (0610 Salisbury to Exeter St Davids) in the morning.


I've not heard anything either yet but agree with Phil.  The only reason Pinhoe extensions haven't happened yet is because it hasn't been possible to train enough crews due to the pandemic.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: PhilWakely on January 23, 2022, 18:08:25
The only reason Pinhoe extensions haven't happened yet is because it hasn't been possible to train enough crews due to the pandemic.

3Z50 (1511 Exeter TMD to Castle Cary) and 3Z51 (1747 Castle Cary to Exeter TMD) - the GWR route-refreshers for HSS drivers are back in the schedule. However, judging by last week, they are not stopping at Pinhoe nor Axminster, so I am not entirely certain whether these runs will be useful for these Barnstaple extensions.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: REVUpminster on January 23, 2022, 22:22:34
GWR must be confident they will have the stock as an extra train would be needed and also another one for Okehampton.
The 769s must be coming on stream at Reading to release the 165s which are also being refurbished.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: infoman on January 24, 2022, 06:29:51
Shame the three councils of Somerset Dorset and Wiltshire can't get together and get a continued journey to Salisbury


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: grahame on January 24, 2022, 08:06:31
Shame the three councils of Somerset Dorset and Wiltshire can't get together and get a continued journey to Salisbury

I don't know about that one ... I will leave it to the "line experts" to comment but looking back at old timetables, I would suspect that the 30 minute services at each end - into Exeter from Axminster and into Salisbury and east thereof from Yeovil Junction are somewhat separate commuter flows in terms of justifying the extra service.  But, please, convince me otherwise.

If we're doing a "total review", I know I've oft advocated the extension of the Romsey 6 up to (and beyond) Westbury, but would a good use of the train that sits in the bay at Salisbury be an onward service to Yeovil (Pen Mill, via Junction) rather than extending the slower of the two trains in the hour coming into Salisbury from Basingstoke?   I had better stop writing before I suggest something REALLLY silly that forgets it's a single line!


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: REVUpminster on January 24, 2022, 14:09:09
In the December 2019 timetable SWR used to run between the 16.25 , 17.25, 1825 London trains a 1639 to Honiton not stopping at Cranbrook or Feniton and an 1746 Axminster all stations.

Arrivals in the morning at Exeter were more complicated 0635 from Axminster, 0742 from Gillingham, 0822 and 0944 from Salisbury, before settling down to xx43 arrivals from London.

Devon Metro was always intended to replace theses services.

Hopefully stock should not be a problem as 769s at Reading displace 165s west.
An extra train would be needed as would another for the hourly Okehampton service from May.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: paul7575 on February 08, 2022, 18:03:12
Following up this subject in the latest track access applications on NR’s website, they have only applied for contingent rights to the 3 public services, on the basis that SWR May reinstate their own short workings in Dec 22.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: DaveHarries on February 10, 2022, 00:11:45
The only extension I can see so far runs on Mondays to Fridays only which is that the 1639 Barnstaple to Exeter Central is retimed to depart Barnstaple at 1631 and runs through to Axminster. After Exeter Central this will call at Pinhoe, Cranbrook, Feniton and Honiton before arriving Axminster at 1828.

The unfortunate thing with this is that the train on this trip then works ECS to Exeter TMD on a lengthy schedule: the working leaves Axminster at 1847 and heads to Castle Cary with a pause at Chard Junction (28 minutes) and arrives at Castle Cary at 1952, It then leaves Castle Cary at 2036 and runs to GWR's depot at Exeter, via. Yeovil, Axminster and Honiton with pauses at Chard Junction (6 minutes), Honiton (28 minutes) and Exeter St. Davids (4 minutes because the train reverses direction there) before arriving at the depot at 2225. Makes a good route refresher for the drivers but rather a long one: a siding at Axminster would surely be a good idea? https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45741/2022-05-16/detailed

Dave


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: bradshaw on February 10, 2022, 08:38:29
Relay the old Lyme Regis bay on the up platform. Then the service could wait for the down and up Waterloos which cross here. It could thus serve as a connection into and out of the London services which could run Honiton and Exeter only.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: Mark A on February 10, 2022, 09:54:07


The unfortunate thing with this is that the train on this trip then works ECS to Exeter TMD on a lengthy schedule: the working leaves Axminster at 1847 and heads to Castle Cary with a pause at Chard Junction (28 minutes) and arrives at Castle Cary at 1952, It then leaves Castle Cary at 2036 and runs to GWR's depot at Exeter, via. Yeovil, Axminster and Honiton with pauses at Chard Junction (6 minutes), Honiton (28 minutes) and Exeter St. Davids (4 minutes because the train reverses direction there) before arriving at the depot at 2225. Makes a good route refresher for the drivers but rather a long one: a siding at Axminster would surely be a good idea? https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45741/2022-05-16/detailed

Dave

68 miles there and back? That's just embarrassing, considering that I recently recall more than one railway manager arguing in respect of the Bristol to Waterloo services "Well we can't be expected to run trains carrying fresh air, 'cos environmental impact".


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: RichardB on February 10, 2022, 10:01:53


The unfortunate thing with this is that the train on this trip then works ECS to Exeter TMD on a lengthy schedule: the working leaves Axminster at 1847 and heads to Castle Cary with a pause at Chard Junction (28 minutes) and arrives at Castle Cary at 1952, It then leaves Castle Cary at 2036 and runs to GWR's depot at Exeter, via. Yeovil, Axminster and Honiton with pauses at Chard Junction (6 minutes), Honiton (28 minutes) and Exeter St. Davids (4 minutes because the train reverses direction there) before arriving at the depot at 2225. Makes a good route refresher for the drivers but rather a long one: a siding at Axminster would surely be a good idea? https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45741/2022-05-16/detailed

Dave

68 miles there and back? That's just embarrassing, considering that I recently recall more than one railway manager arguing in respect of the Bristol to Waterloo services "Well we can't be expected to run trains carrying fresh air, 'cos environmental impact".

These trains are bound to replace the route refreshers mentioned by Phil Wakely above.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: REVUpminster on February 10, 2022, 11:44:07
This train is only replacing the SWR 1746 Exeter St David's-to Axminster from the pre-covid timetable. I think the SWR then went empty to Salisbury.

It will be interesting what stock is used as Exeter depot uses 158s 166s and 150s to Barnstaple and there might be 165s as well after May.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: PhilWakely on February 10, 2022, 13:51:50
This train is only replacing the SWR 1746 Exeter St David's-to Axminster from the pre-covid timetable. I think the SWR then went empty to Salisbury.

It will be interesting what stock is used as Exeter depot uses 158s 166s and 150s to Barnstaple and there might be 165s as well after May.

Both the SWR 'locals' returned to Exeter - one in service, the other as ECS.

The Turbos have not be gauge checked between Exmouth Junction and Axminster and, as far as I am aware, there are currently no plans to use them on the Axminsters.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: grahame on February 10, 2022, 14:31:09
The Turbos have not be gauge checked between Exmouth Junction and Axminster and, as far as I am aware, there are currently no plans to use them on the Axminsters.

I suspect we're at something of a "pinch point" at the moment with regional / local stock shortage in Bristol and Exeter.  Once the 769s come into substantial service from Reading, Turbos cascade to Bristol and then more / most 158s move from there to Exeter giving more 15x stock available for services from there ... such as an hourly service to Okehampton, the extras to Axminster, and longer trains in the South West for the Sumer leisure traffic.

Will the 769s be into service by May?

What will users of the Cardiff - Portsmouth and connecting services in Wessex think of the stock changes? We are tired of short, overcrowded trains and will welcome them rising up to the five carriages, but we remain unhappy with a degrading from the regional class 158 trains to suburban units of classes 165 and 166.  Suburban units are fine for what they were designed and bought for - and that's services such as the stoppers to Severn Beach and to Weston-super-mare where the mid carriage doors help, but that are far from clever on long distance journeys.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: REVUpminster on February 10, 2022, 23:01:45
I am sure I read the Barnstaple users prefer the 166s on the peak hour trains. A 166 worked 3 days last week.

The March Todays Railways had 10 158s (All the 2 coaches) transferred Exeter to Bristol and the 7 (all 3 coaches) transferred Bristol to Exeter in service now.

Exeter's new shed has been built to handle 3 coach trains and has a lifting road that can exchange bogies.

I also read that when the 165s (16 are three coach) come west from Reading they will end up at Exeter and by the end of the year the 150s could be gone. It all rests on the 769s coming into service which I hear isn't going all that well.

There are 20 150s at Exeter for the 7 trains (2 units on many) on the Paignton-Exmouth, 2 Okehampton from May and 5 for the rest of the branches in Devon and Cornwall. They are usually supplemented by 3 Turbos rotating down from Bristol for use on the local Exeter services (Devon Metro).

So if Exeter ended up with 16 165s and 7 158s all three coach the GWR could claim newer trains more seats throughout Devon and Cornwall and into the 2030s a newer greener  train will probably have been developed because the turbos and castle sets will be life expired.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: DaveHarries on February 11, 2022, 00:24:31
Will the 769s be into service by May?[/b]
Given the issues that Transport for Wales have had with them - they were used on the Rhymney to Cardiff route and the fact that a loco was, until recently, kept at Rhymney in case it was needed to rescue a 769: it was called out quite a few times - says rather a lot. I was at Oxford for work recently and thought I could see 3 green 769s in the sidings north of the station but am not certain about that.

[...]but we remain unhappy with a degrading from the regional class 158 trains to suburban units of classes 165 and 166.  Suburban units are fine for what they were designed and bought for - and that's services such as the stoppers to Severn Beach and to Weston-super-mare where the mid carriage doors help, but that are far from clever on long distance journeys.
Yes I always thought that the 158s did a very good job on the Cardiff to Portsmouth route and always enjoyed seeing them on the Severn Beach line as we did a few times before the pandemic: they performed well on that route too. I hope the 166s will continue to work the Severn Beach line.

Dave


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: DaveHarries on February 26, 2022, 01:37:07
I see that, according to RTT, the ECS from the Barnstaple - Axminster service back to Exeter TMD runs to a different route and schedule on Thursdays with a running time that is about 75 minutes shorter.

Mondays - Wednesdays & Fridays: 5L90 Axminster - Yeovil - Castle Cary - Yeovil - Axminster - Exeter TMD
https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45741/2022-05-18/detailed

Thursdays: 5C90 Axminster - Yeovil - Castle Cary - Taunton - Exeter TMD
https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45742/2022-05-19/detailed

Dave


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: PhilWakely on February 27, 2022, 20:30:38
I see that, according to RTT, the ECS from the Barnstaple - Axminster service back to Exeter TMD runs to a different route and schedule on Thursdays with a running time that is about 75 minutes shorter.

Mondays - Wednesdays & Fridays: 5L90 Axminster - Yeovil - Castle Cary - Yeovil - Axminster - Exeter TMD
https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45741/2022-05-18/detailed

Thursdays: 5C90 Axminster - Yeovil - Castle Cary - Taunton - Exeter TMD
https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:W45742/2022-05-19/detailed

Dave

Given the number of times that the current driver refresher pairing, 5Z30 and 5Z31, has been cancelled recently (I think it has only run on three occasions in the last month??), I strongly suspect that the vast majority of these BNP-AXM services (if they do actually start) will be cancelled after Exeter Central due to ‘lack of drivers’.  If the service does run through to Axminster, I would not be surprised to see the 5C90 and 5L90 runs replaced by a simple ECS working back from Axminster to Exeter TMD via Honiton.


Title: Re: Peak time Barnstaple services to be extended to/from Axminster?
Post by: vacman on March 20, 2022, 19:54:29
This train is only replacing the SWR 1746 Exeter St David's-to Axminster from the pre-covid timetable. I think the SWR then went empty to Salisbury.

It will be interesting what stock is used as Exeter depot uses 158s 166s and 150s to Barnstaple and there might be 165s as well after May.

Both the SWR 'locals' returned to Exeter - one in service, the other as ECS.

The Turbos have not be gauge checked between Exmouth Junction and Axminster and, as far as I am aware, there are currently no plans to use them on the Axminsters.

Not quite, the second short working, the 17:46 from Exeter to Axminster used to terminate Axminster then run ECS to Salisbury via Castle Cary and Westbury as a route refresh turn for Salisbury drivers



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net