Great Western Coffee Shop

Journey by Journey => London to Reading => Topic started by: sanfrandragon on May 30, 2023, 10:22:45



Title: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: sanfrandragon on May 30, 2023, 10:22:45
The new timetable has probably been discussed elsewhere, but this is specifically for Maidenhead to Paddington.  It looks like the 06.46 and the 07.16 have both been axed, leaving the only fast train during this prime commuter time as the 7.02, leaving Maidenhead feeling less connected than before; surely a retrograde step.  And good luck to the developers trying to sell the monstrosity flats in the town center as commuting to London becomes less practical!


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Oxonhutch on May 30, 2023, 11:36:55
Looking at Realtimetrains and the new T10 GWR timetable there are non-stop MAI-PAD services at 0633, 0702, 0707, 0733, 0736, 0802, 0831 and 0905, each taking about 19 minutes into London.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Electric train on May 31, 2023, 06:47:37
There are also some semi fast Elizabeth Line services with only intermediate stops at Burnham, Slough, West Drayton and Ealing Broadway 38 mins to Padd instead of the 43 mins.

Whilst the 345's lack facilities, toilets, charging points and the seats are not the most comfortable where the Elizabeth Line does win is it removes the need in many cases to change trains at Paddington which can take more time than people often take into account.

Maidenhead does now have a very good level of service all day, 2 tph, now faster, GWR to Padd only calling at Slough, in under 30 mins and 4 Elizabeth Line in around 40 min. 


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: sanfrandragon on May 31, 2023, 10:29:03
Looking at Realtimetrains and the new T10 GWR timetable there are non-stop MAI-PAD services at 0633, 0702, 0707, 0733, 0736, 0802, 0831 and 0905, each taking about 19 minutes into London.

I cant find that 7.07 on the GWR website.  Ex the 7.36 which looks ambitious, the service has gone to roughly every half hour in that peak period.  Higher fares for a worse service.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Electric train on May 31, 2023, 12:49:07
Looking at Realtimetrains and the new T10 GWR timetable there are non-stop MAI-PAD services at 0633, 0702, 0707, 0733, 0736, 0802, 0831 and 0905, each taking about 19 minutes into London.

I cant find that 7.07 on the GWR website.  Ex the 7.36 which looks ambitious, the service has gone to roughly every half hour in that peak period.  Higher fares for a worse service.

Its 07:02 not 07:07, why do you say the 07:36 is ambitious?

Slough have it even worse, nothing in the morning peak much under 30 min, National Rail Journey Planner at some times gives the option to travel to Maidenhead and change ??? ??? although it only save a few mins

 


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: TaplowGreen on May 31, 2023, 14:13:50
Looking at Realtimetrains and the new T10 GWR timetable there are non-stop MAI-PAD services at 0633, 0702, 0707, 0733, 0736, 0802, 0831 and 0905, each taking about 19 minutes into London.

I cant find that 7.07 on the GWR website.  Ex the 7.36 which looks ambitious, the service has gone to roughly every half hour in that peak period.  Higher fares for a worse service.

Its 07:02 not 07:07, why do you say the 07:36 is ambitious?

Slough have it even worse, nothing in the morning peak much under 30 min, National Rail Journey Planner at some times gives the option to travel to Maidenhead and change ??? ??? although it only save a few mins

 

I'd say for a lot of people out West though the benefits the Elizabeth Line bring in terms of not having to change at Paddington outweigh the loss of one or two fast services to Paddington?


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: sanfrandragon on May 31, 2023, 15:39:34
Looking at Realtimetrains and the new T10 GWR timetable there are non-stop MAI-PAD services at 0633, 0702, 0707, 0733, 0736, 0802, 0831 and 0905, each taking about 19 minutes into London.

I cant find that 7.07 on the GWR website.  Ex the 7.36 which looks ambitious, the service has gone to roughly every half hour in that peak period.  Higher fares for a worse service.

Its 07:02 not 07:07, why do you say the 07:36 is ambitious?

Slough have it even worse, nothing in the morning peak much under 30 min, National Rail Journey Planner at some times gives the option to travel to Maidenhead and change ??? ??? although it only save a few mins

 

I guess a typo from Oxenhutch on 7.02/7.07.

Ambitious because running a fast service 3 minutes behind another fast service seems likely to be impractical and an anomaly that will get cut in any future new timetable.

A 'good service' and 'better than Slough' can't hide the fact it's not as good as it was in that peak time.  And for more money.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Oxonhutch on May 31, 2023, 17:20:08
I guess a typo from Oxenhutch on 7.02/7.07.

No it's in the timetable but as it is ex-Oxford it may be cancelled with the bridge repairs


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: NickB on June 07, 2023, 15:04:52
I’m very much with sanfrandragon on this topic - the current timetable (especially with the 07.07 that has never run) is a significant deterioration in service for Maidenhead since the introduction of the Elizabeth Line and I’ve written to our MP to state the same.

We used to have a direct non-stop service every 10mins (average) from 06.30 until 08.00 and now we have shorter services once every half hour.

Taking the 07.33 as an example - that was full and standing upon arrival at Maidenhead yesterday.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: IndustryInsider on June 07, 2023, 15:58:27
The 07:07 will presumably resume next week?


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Oxonhutch on June 07, 2023, 20:32:07
Taking the 07.33 as an example - that was full and standing upon arrival at Maidenhead yesterday.

Would it not be best to step back and wait for the 0736?

That service starts at Reading, misses Twyford and acts as a relief for the 0733.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: paul7575 on June 07, 2023, 21:10:40
Local MPs on the route pushed like mad for quite a few years for Crossrail to be extended to Reading. 

A great example of being careful what you wish for.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: stuving on June 07, 2023, 21:55:46
Taking the 07.33 as an example - that was full and standing upon arrival at Maidenhead yesterday.

Would it not be best to step back and wait for the 0736?

That service starts at Reading, misses Twyford and acts as a relief for the 0733.

The 0736 starts from Newbury. These two trains are on different platforms (4 and 2) and only three minutes apart, so you have to pick one to go for. The same is true of the 0702 and 0707, at five minutes apart - I guess it's feasible to go for both of those, but a bit risky.

The 0646 from Oxford should also be able to start next week, if that helps.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: Electric train on June 08, 2023, 06:42:51
The morning services and evening "commuter" services at Maidenhead have been impacted by the line closure between Didcot and Oxford next week should see this improve.   The levels of service have been impacted by the DfT (aka Treasury) taking the stance that rail commuter usage is at 70% of pre-Covid levels, this was based on figures last Autumn / Winter however now the industry believes the return is closer to 80 + % and in places 90%, however its not consistent during the week Mondays (Boom Town Rats day I don't like Mondays) and Fridays commuter passenger numbers are lower that Tue to Thur.

The DfT have placed a lot of pressure on the rail industry cut train / reduce services to reduce costs to the Treasury.


As a side note Monday I did travel off peak from Furze Platt to Euston, it was the quickest I have ever done it off peak just about an hour from boarding the train at FZP and arriving on the concourse at EUS.  The GWR off peak "fasts" with the connection off of the branch is an improvement.


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: NickB on June 15, 2023, 18:49:51
Maidenhead Advertiser are reporting the reintroduction of the 07.16 fast (via Slough) to paddington


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: sanfrandragon on July 13, 2023, 13:36:58
Maidenhead Advertiser are reporting the reintroduction of the 07.16 fast (via Slough) to paddington

Sounds like your letter had some impact!


Title: Re: Maidenhead timetable changes
Post by: NickB on July 14, 2023, 09:01:33
Lol - I can claim no personal responsibility but I am very pleased with the outcome.

It does go to show that sometimes there is actually some leeway to be found when organisations like Network Rail and GWR say that something ‘simply can’t be done’.



This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net