The relief train to Plymouth and the resulant superfast run of the regular Penzance train are for the summer only. The extra train has other things to do come the autumn. The path IS being kept so that it can be run again when appropriate amd there's a train to do it. So not really a long term thing for Plymouth.
There is what I read as widespread early concern amongst the informed and interested in the community, and indeed in GWR▸ , at the effect the closures for six years over the Christmas period - ranging from 2 days some years to 18 years in other years - is going to upset passengers, as will extra stops if they are to be aded thereafter at Old Oak. There is a feeling that the new station will bring very few benefits / new travel opportunities to GWR passengers who are having to "pay" for it with extra disruption and slower journeys. But I suspect at the end of the day people will just put up with the disruption and slowing, with the wider community getting a bit upset nearer the time it actually happens, but then learning to live with the changes that are permanent.
How much MPs▸ are briefed, by who, whether they choose to take these briefings / inputs further and what they look to achieve by doing so will vary between them. It was very interesting to see the different ways our local MPs in Wiltshire and BaNES reacted to the news that well used through services to and from London were to be withdrawn, and the murky and dirty way that had been decided. Some made very strong and public inputs in support of the services (not that it saved the services), other talked of going in to see the minister and raising it with him - but the way this was reported left it very unclear as to whether the MP in question had made a strong input on our behalf, or had assured the minister that if he stuck to his guns it would blow over.
Thanks for providing an objective, informed and reasonable answer to my question, Graham. Though I think you meant 18 days and not 18 years!
Still waiting any more insight as to whether the 19:04 is being badly crowded with Reading passengers on a Friday?