|
Title: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: bobm on August 04, 2026, 17:03:11 I probably have too much time on my hands, but came across this combination of words for the steam railway ticket office in
Anyone else found some standout ones? Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Bob_Blakey on August 05, 2026, 07:54:34 Dartmouth :)
Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: JayMac on August 05, 2026, 23:06:59 fence.gross.bats - Buckingham Palace
beats.member.daily - Long Island, NY Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Western Pathfinder on August 06, 2026, 07:37:49 Plankton.issue.hopeless.
Pilning Station ………. Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Richard Fairhurst on August 06, 2026, 08:38:17 dont (https://cybergibbons.com/security-2/why-what3words-is-not-suitable-for-safety-critical-applications/).privatise (https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2019/03/why-bother-with-what-three-words/).addresses (https://www.reddit.com/r/911dispatchers/comments/olcxdv/what3words_and_why_its_trash/)
Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: JohnM on August 06, 2026, 09:34:38 dont (https://cybergibbons.com/security-2/why-what3words-is-not-suitable-for-safety-critical-applications/).privatise (https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2019/03/why-bother-with-what-three-words/).addresses (https://www.reddit.com/r/911dispatchers/comments/olcxdv/what3words_and_why_its_trash/) Clicked on those links - interesting, didn't know about all the problems with w3w :oTitle: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: ChrisB on August 06, 2026, 14:04:22 Yes, very good pints are made.
If you have mobile reception to access w3w, why not access Google Maps & send a location link??!! ::) Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: JohnM on August 06, 2026, 15:46:35 If you have mobile reception to access w3w, why not access Google Maps & send a location link??!! ::) Don't know how long that's been around but I only found out about it last week, by accident when I sent an "I'm here" text to my wife and my phone asked if I wanted to send a live location link. Nice feature.Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Ralph Ayres on August 06, 2026, 21:49:40 Having used OS grid references since I was a 10 year old Cub I've mostly regraded w3w as a solution looking for a problem. It's unnecessarily precise for most purposes and can't be adjusted; my front door and garden gate don't need different references to find my house, with another again if you're on the road instead of the pavement! OS can do 1km squares for a rough area, or 100m for greater accuracy by which stage you should generally be able to find the thing you're looking for. Then there's Google Maps. Both can be generated by phones just as easily as w3w and don't end up giving you words that you have to spell out.
w3w is perhaps the Trainline of mapping. Not actually bad, but got where it has by good marketing and so coming to the attention of people who hadn't realised there was any other way of doing it. Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: rogerpatenall on August 07, 2026, 08:17:22 Can be useful for summoning the emergency services.
I can remember when I was working a not insignificant fire at a factory. The person calling the FB gave what she believed to be the post code and the fire tenders turned up at the sorting office in the nearby city. Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Electric train on August 07, 2026, 08:33:55 If you have mobile reception to access w3w, why not access Google Maps & send a location link??!! ::) Don't know how long that's been around but I only found out about it last week, by accident when I sent an "I'm here" text to my wife and my phone asked if I wanted to send a live location link. Nice feature.2013, it really took off and used by the blue light services during the pandemic. Having used OS grid references since I was a 10 year old Cub I've mostly regraded w3w as a solution looking for a problem. It's unnecessarily precise for most purposes and can't be adjusted; my front door and garden gate don't need different references to find my house, with another again if you're on the road instead of the pavement! OS can do 1km squares for a rough area, or 100m for greater accuracy by which stage you should generally be able to find the thing you're looking for. Then there's Google Maps. Both can be generated by phones just as easily as w3w and don't end up giving you words that you have to spell out. w3w is perhaps the Trainline of mapping. Not actually bad, but got where it has by good marketing and so coming to the attention of people who hadn't realised there was any other way of doing it. What 3 Words is not just a UK specific locator, also it is simpler than the 2 letter and 8 digit grid ref system and a lot less prone to errors over radio / mobile phone. When I was at work we needed to list access points and electrical substations on the railway for use when dealing with the blue light services, the options where ELR - very railway specific that no one outside the industry recognises Post Code - not all railway access points / equipment locations have a post code, are near an address with a post code or the nearest post code is on the oposite side of the railway which by road could be 10 miles away! Grid ref - These are used but even the 2 letter 6 digit are prone to errors Lat/long - Not practical What 3 Words - after post codes this was the first choice by the blue light services, even if you are out by a few squares it far simpler and more reliable than G/R Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Ralph Ayres on August 07, 2026, 11:04:09 I must admit on reflection that an early low-tech version of something like w3w would have made my life somewhat easier 30 or so years ago. I had to get packages delivered by road to London Underground stations, and certainly in those days quite a few stations had no post code or building number, or even any real presence at street level, just one or more staircases down from the pavement and possibly a decoy former entrance where lifts had been replaced by escalators in a different location.
Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Chris from Nailsea on August 07, 2026, 11:24:32 Yes, very good pints are made. piled.cuddling.throat for example. ;) :D ;D Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Richard Fairhurst on August 07, 2026, 12:59:16 There's a whole bunch of issues with what3words and they often get tangled up.
I think at its core it's a decent enough idea, for the reasons Electric train has cited - it's easy to remember and communicate, and accurate enough for most purposes. There are genuine technical problems with it, chiefly that the inventors didn't do a good enough job of removing 'soundalike' words. I suspect these are probably fixable - basically, you quietly stop offering those 3m x 3m squares which have soundalike words. That means you go down to 6m x 6m accuracy at that spot, which is still probably good enough. But the real problem is that it's privately owned and copyrighted. Imagine a situation where your address was "11 High Street, Frogtown", but the only way for anyone to find out where that actually was involved paying money to Address Corporation, Inc. That's what3words. Their lawyers repeatedly threaten anyone who attempts to provide an alternative way of working out what3words addresses. The address algorithm itself was invented and settled back in 2013. The entire work of their company since then has been marketing it. They have spent an eight-figure sum on this and barely recouped anything: w3w's losses are astronomical. The only plausible way forward for the company is to be bought by someone big - Amazon, Google, one of the major couriers - but so far they're not biting. Up until now their PR strategy has involved giving free access to emergency services and the like, because it's generated lots of good free publicity. But there's no guarantee this will continue. Tying your location to what3words is making a bet that the next owner of the company won't start charging. That's not a bet I'd make. Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: JohnM on August 07, 2026, 13:35:40 basically, you quietly stop offering those 3m x 3m squares which have soundalike words. That means you go down to 6m x 6m accuracy at that spot <pedant (or dim)>6m x 3m?</pedant>Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: ChrisB on August 07, 2026, 14:36:59 Can be useful for summoning the emergency services. I can remember when I was working a not insignificant fire at a factory. The person calling the FB gave what she believed to be the post code and the fire tenders turned up at the sorting office in the nearby city. It is the emergency services that are asking us NOT to use w3w....and if you can access w3w to obtain their 3 words, you can just as easily access Google Maps & retrieve the live location link? Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: Witham Bobby on August 11, 2026, 13:16:56 I've used w3w a few times, and have the app on my phone (how very modern!)
I don't like that the w3w for my house seems to be different every time I look. Maybe it's got something to do with the house being a 30 bedroom palace? ;) Title: Re: Interesting "What3Words" Post by: grahame on August 13, 2026, 11:04:48 ///kicks.irritable.shop ... somewhat amused because of what you can buy there, how annoyed you can get when you can't find the product you want, and the action you are tempted to take when the machine is out or order.
Topic drift ... BrilliantPeacock4284 SilverWolf6121 CuriousHamster1843 ResilientCaribou791 DynamicSeal940 EmeraldStrawberry4929 EmpatheticFalcon2062 BrilliantKangaroo5708 Some of the "nicknames" seen on current social media posts where people select to have an alter-ego in groups they are members of. I'm concerned at people posting with their own names and also with nicknames in a group and find myself wondering "why?". Having said which, Coffee Shop member names in essence are nicknames / handles. I guess my concern is people having multiple personalities in a group, and using the two supposedly unlinked to setup phishing traps. Hence our "one name/account only" policy here, with a handful of exceptions where good cause is demonstrated. It may surprise readers ... I am personally accepting of anonymous posting where there is reason on such groups - such as where a surprise holiday is being researched. Anyway - to end the aside, Facebook is now giving group admins the ability to turn off posting under nicknames; that will put paid to any discussions of meeting up with Dynamic Seal when on a visit to Budapest, just to discover later that you've set up a clandestine liaison with your own wife. Example fictstious. This page is printed from the "Coffee Shop" forum at http://gwr.passenger.chat which is provided by a customer of Great Western Railway. Views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that content provided contravenes our posting rules ( see http://railcustomer.info/1761 ). The forum is hosted by Well House Consultants - http://www.wellho.net |