It is great that people are using this service but the tickets are really cheap i.e. an anytime single Newcastle to Ashington (about 13 miles) is £2.60; in comparison a Didcot to Oxford (10 miles) anytime single is £8.70. 20p a mile compared with 87p a mile.
Northern is the English TOC▸ with the highest subsidy so not sure how this is affordable, of course ideally we would like all services to be as highly subsidised.
Lets hope that as the fares rise the service continues to be used.
And I do wonder with EWR▸ whether 2 car trains are going to be big enough.
The fares issue is partly down to the Ashington line only having Single tickets and no returns (Single leg pricing). The £2.60 is actually Off Peak, the Anytime Single being £3.00 (
www.brfares.com) - your point about the fares being cheap still holds but, taking that Didcot - Oxford example, the Off Peak Day Return for that is £8.70, just 10p more than the Off Peak Day Single.
Okehampton was opened in 2021 with fares of £4.00 Single, £8.00 Return (both Anytime, no Off Peak fares) Exeter - Okehampton and that's 30 miles. Now £4.60 and £9.20 respectively. In both cases, the railway is being introduced in areas where generations have grown up without it so attractive fares clearly have an important role. I know the great care that was taken with Okehampton.