Is the absence of crew that are able to make the repair during daylight hours a new thing or a recent (past 5yrs) thing?
From a non-expert/passenger perspective it seems remiss not to be able to fix problems for 12+ hours after they occur, but is the logic that the disruption to fix during daylight hours is => than managing the closed line for a day?
Very good question, certainly the habit of routinely forecasting disruption "until the end of the day" seems quite a recent development.
I too do find the idea that there is no-one available from Network Rail to react to this type of incident for 12 hours incredible, especially given the significance, and state of the infrastructure in the Paddington-Reading area - these are hardly isolated incidents.
I suspect that the issue may relate to access for staff to a live railway. In older day and you still see it in other counties, trains run on adjacent lines while work is ongoing but in order to reduce / eliminate as far as possible casualties, it's very rare if at all these days. So that means as nighttime stoppage ...
I feel for staff having to put a time on disruption and how long it will go on. The honest thing to say is "we don't know" but that is not helpful without an estimate, and systems are not set up to say "probably" and "possibly" and "if we're lucky", and I'm not sure how such terms and information would be taken by members of the public who are less analytic than readers here.
There is are a number of reasons why the repair cannot be undertaken in the day.
NR» has geared up it workforce to carryout maintenance on track to nights, for a number of reasons first is workforce safety, the
ORR» has made it quite clear to NR that working on a !live" railway is basically no longer permitted without very stringent control measures, second is performance maintenance during the day would impact on service performance.
On and Off tracking the OTM's (on track machines) to move the equipment and materials to site during normal train running is high risk, also the OTM's may be in the wrong place and need transporting by road.
If a temporary repair could have been made then it would have with reduced speed.
The question that I am sure the Route and
TOCs▸ will be asking is why yet another "catastrophic" broken rail on the Western ML