[edit] -
split from https://www.firstgreatwestern.info/coffeeshop/index.php?topic=30912.0 which is about the new station at Newsham where the local bus company has services passing close by but not calling at the new facilities.I can understand both "sides" of this ... it sounds depressingly familiar. It feels like madness but yet when you talk to the bus companies, you can understand why - at least we can / could locally where we have a similar situation. That's a bus stop at the station, but it's only used for rail replacement services. Service buses pass by 150 metres away at the top of Station Approach, though it is 450 metres to the nearest stop (271/2/3) and 550 metres to the stop on the x34. And it's about 650 metres to the Town Bridge.
Diverting the 271/2/3 via the station bus stop would cost somewhere from 3 to 5 minutes. The x34 would be 3 minutes northbound and twice that southbound. And that would mean not only would
through passenger journeys be slowed down, but also that an
extra vehicle would be needed for the 27x, and an extra vehicle for the x34 - or
frequencies reduced and
no longer would the services run clockface.
There is - err - some confusion locally about how far from the station it's realistic to have a bus stop / walk. A Wiltshire Councillor who represents a ward on the 271/2/3 route that's on the opposite side of Melksham to the station tells me that the 450 metre walk from the station to the bus stop is reasonable and should not put anyone off, but the 650 metres to the town bridge and town centre is not a reasonable walk. My own view is that for a transfer from the bus, this is really too far - especialy as it involves crossing a busy A road at a point that there's no crossing and traffic appears quick and blind, but then the distance to the Town Bridge, which does not involve crossing any roads on the level isn't a problem if you're headed to the Town Centre.
Of course, the look is for solutions.
* The local authorities (ours, and up north) could cross palms with silver - or perhaps it would need to be gold - to make it commercially worthwhile.
* A bus service could run that actually terminates at the station, and indeed this is a solution for Melksham. We lost our 2nd town bus vehicle during covid - "driver shortage" and it never came back - it could so usefully now fill the gap with an hourly route leaving the station just after the train calls, and gettig back there just before the next train.
* Bus stops could be added at the top of Station Approach. Very easy in the x34 both ways, and inbound on the 271/2/3 - in all three cases two traffic lanes, and no need for pedestrians to cross on the level. The fourth is a bit of a problem, and perhaps the outbound bus towards Bath COULD divert down Station Approach at the request of passengers onboard.
I hope and expect that Newsham has various options such as these; I also hope that they can get them sorted in a tiny fraction of the time that we have been pushing, nagging, campaigning for an attractive bus <-> train solution
