Gosh, a very deep dive!
That song has come into my head a couple of times recently while waiting at St Erth for the train to St Ives.
Beeching's report probably got it about half-right, on balance. The half he got wrong will still be haunting us 100 years from now..
Some of the biggest travesties were lines proposed for retention but never the less closed - Oxford to Cambridge, trains to Swanage and to Kingswear, Cheltenham Spa to Stratford-upon-Avon. Perhaps these haunt us even more than some of the Beeching proposals that were implemented such as Minehead, Tavistock and Portishead.
Yes - relieved for the current users that lines like St Ives, Exmouth and Avonmouth were saved though proposed for closure.