What i think it just shows how stupid fares are has I know that this happens all over the system and I thought this section was the place to discuss.
You were quite right to raise your question here, basset44 - and I'm glad our members were able to help with practical suggestions!
I, too, have expressed amazement here in the past, that by buying two separate tickets for my journey, rather than one, while sitting on the same train throughout, I can save ^30 or ^40.
It is absolute nonsense.
