I agree that there is a case for a guard (for want of a better name) on trains.
And why could they not take on the trolley dolly (molly) role? Is there any good reason why the traditional “Guard” role could not be modelled on that of a modern air host(ess)?
At the moment, since introduction of the
IETs▸ I am lead to believe that Train Managers are being pushed to focus more on revenue - they no longer release the doors nor need to manually operate Selective Door Operation. Obviously, Train Managers can’t be monitored at all times to see if they are doing revenue inspections however there will still be the odd few who don’t really bother, just close the doors and let the automatic announcements roll.
If
GWR▸ ever choose to get rid of the safety critical guard then I would be shocked if they don’t come back in the format of “On Board Supervisor” or something like that. Making so many people redundant won’t go down well..